Abstract:The inherent complexity of high‐diversity systems can make them particularly difficult to understand. The relatively recent introduction of functional approaches, which seek to infer ecosystem functioning based on species’ ecological traits, has revolutionized our understanding of these high‐diversity systems. Today, the functional structure of an assemblage is widely regarded as a key indicator of the status or resilience of an ecosystem. Indeed, functional evaluations have become a mainstay of monitoring and management approaches. But is the heavy focus on broad metrics of functional structure grounded in empirical research? On tropical coral reefs, the ocean’s most diverse ecosystems, remarkably few studies directly quantify ecosystem functions and the term ‘function’ is widely used but rarely defined, especially when applied to reef fishes. Our review suggests that most ‘functional’ studies do not study function as it relates to ecological processes. Rather, they look at easy‐to‐measure traits or proxies that are thought to have functional significance. However, these links are rarely tested empirically, severely limiting our capacity to extend results from community structure to the dynamic processes operating within high‐diversity ecosystems such as coral reefs. With rapid changes in global ecosystems, and in their capacity to deliver ecosystem services, there is an urgent need to understand and empirically measure the role of organisms in various ecosystem functions. We suggest that if we are to understand and manage transitioning coral reefs in the Anthropocene, a broad definition of the word ‘function’ is needed along with a focus on ecological processes and the empirical quantification of functional roles. In this review, we propose a universal operational definition of the term ‘function’ that works from a cellular to a global level. Specifically, it is the movement or storage of energy or material. Within this broad definitional framework, all functions are part of a continuum that is tied together by the process‐based unifier of material fluxes. With this universal definition at hand, we then present a path forward that will allow us to fully harness the power of functional approaches in understanding and managing high‐diversity systems such as coral reefs. A plain language summary is available for this article. Plain Language Summary

A quantitative definition of organismality and its application to lichen

Organisms and Organization

Unifying concepts of biological function from molecules to ecosystems

About Organisms. A Teaser

Ecosystems with mutually exclusive interactions self-organize to a state of high diversity

Return of the organism? The concept in plant biology, now and then

Functional Basis of Microorganism Classification

Biological organicism and the ethics of the human-nature relationship

Host Biology in Light of the Microbiome: Ten Principles of Holobionts and Hologenomes

Symbionts out of sync: Decoupled physiological responses are widespread and ecologically important in lichen associations

Stable States of Biological Organisms

The quest for the definition of life

Lichen physiological traits and growth forms affect communities of associated invertebrates

Paradigm lost: reconsidering functional form and group hypotheses in marine ecology

A simple model for the formation of a complex organism

The meaning of the term ‘function’ in ecology: A coral reef perspective

Multipartite complexity of the lichen symbiosis revealed by metagenome and transcriptome analysis of Xanthoria parietina

Endless forms of endless formation — The morphogenesis of organisms and scientific objects

Factors shaping the assembly of lichen holobionts in a tropical lichen community

The origin of allometric scaling laws in biology from genomes to ecosystems: towards a quantitative unifying theory of biological structure and organization

Methods for quantifying self-organization in biology: a forward-looking survey and tutorial