Comment on "Mode Structure and Orbital Angular Momentum of Spatiotemporal Optical Vortex (STOV) Pulses"

Miguel A. Porras

2024-03-01

Abstract:We report a mathematical error and a misinterpretation in

Optics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

Clarification of the transverse orbital angular momentum of spatiotemporal optical vortices

Miguel Angel Porras

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1088/2040-8986/ad645a

IF: 2.1

2024-07-18

Journal of Optics

Abstract:Advances in the generation and the application of spatiotemporal optical vortices (STOV) are proceeding fast, but fundamental aspects of their nature remain obscure. Phys. Rev. A 107, L031501 (2023) (PRA) and Prog. Electromagn. Res. 177, 95 (2023) (PIER) provide contradictory results on the transverse orbital angular momentum (OAM) carried by STOVs. We show that the results by Porras in PIER and by Bliokh in PRA refer to different STOVs and are all correct. In PIER, STOVs are elliptical at given cross section and time, or in space-time, but not in three-dimensional space. In PRA, STOVs are elliptical in space but not in space-time. This is evidenced from two dual, equivalent theories on the transverse OAM where a wave packet is seen in space-time evolving with propagation distance or in space evolving in time, that accounts for all values of the total, intrinsic and extrinsic OAM in PIERS and PRA. However, the intrinsic OAM with respect to the photon wave function center in PRA is not generally conserved, which advocates for the energy center in PIER as the STOV center. We argue that STOVs are generated in experiments to purportedly have elliptical symmetry in space-time. The values provided in PIER should then be taken as the reference for elliptical STOVs, and the theory therein to evaluate the transverse OAM of other wave packets. Hancock {\it et al.} in Phys. Rev. Lett. 127, 193901 (2021) and Phys. Rev. X. 14, 011031 (2024) erroneously attribute the transverse OAM of elliptical STOVs in space to the elliptical STOVs in space-time they consider theoretically and can generate in their experiments.

optics
Quantized Optical Orbital Angular Momentum Precession and Nutation in a Twisted Light

Zhuoyuan Wang,Shi Yao Chong,Peihong Cheng,Peng An,Jian Qi Shen

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1088/1402-4896/aba0f8

2020-01-01

Physica Scripta

Abstract:In a subject of ‘optical angular momentum (OAM) and optical vortex’, a twisted light (also referred to as a ‘spiralling optical field’) possesses a helical wavefront. Recently, a new advance in the twisted light is Rego et al's discovery of self-torque effect that can cause an intrinsic angular acceleration (DOI:10.1126/science.aaw9486). Such a self-torque effect gives rise to a time-varying optical orbital angular momentum. Then we believe that the time-dependent OAM of this vortex laser beam can lead to non-trivial evolution of the OAM state vector. It is expected that the information on the self-torque of a twisted optical field might be reflected in an extra phase shift and, based on this, we study the possible precession and nutation evolution of a quantized optical orbital angular momentum in such a twisted light. The relevant effects such as non-cyclic non-adiabatic ‘geometric’ phase and dynamical phase due to the angular momentum precession and nutation in the vortex beam are also included. An effective Hamiltonian characterizing the optical vortex precession and nutation is constructed and the time-dependent wave equation is solved. The result obtained in this paper could be utilized in treating the polarization evolution and possible mechanical (force) effect of twisted optical fields that can exhibit the self-torque phenomenon.
Spatio-temporal optical vortices: principles of description and basic properties

Aleksandr Bekshaev

2024-06-23

Abstract:These notes appeared as a summary during the initial acquaintance with the structure and properties of spatio-temporal optical vortices (STOV), as these are presented in the current literature. The general approach to the STOV description and characterization is based on the model of scalar paraxial Gaussian wave packet. On this ground, the STOV structures of arbitrary orders are considered as superpositions of spatio-temporal Hermite-Gaussian modes. This representation enables the direct and physically meaningful characterization of the STOV amplitude and phase distributions, their evolution upon free propagation and in optical systems, internal energy flows and the orbital angular momentum. The topologically determined asymmetry and the difference between the "energy center" and "probability center" [Phys. Rev. A 107, L031501 (2023)] is discussed and qualitatively interpreted. Methods for the STOV generation and diagnostics are outlined, and the main properties of non-Gaussian (Bessel-type) STOVs are briefly described. The notes may be useful as initial introduction to the STOV-associated ideas and their extraordinary properties.

Optics
Orbital angular momentum of optical, acoustic, and quantum-mechanical spatiotemporal vortex pulses

Konstantin Y. Bliokh

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevA.107.L031501

2023-03-17

Physical Review A - Atomic, Molecular, and Optical Physics

Abstract:Motivated by recent progress in the generation of optical spatiotemporal vortex pulses (STVPs), there is a theoretical discussion about the transverse orbital angular momentum (OAM) carried by such pulses. Two recent works [K. Y. Bliokh, Phys. Rev. Lett. 126 , 243601 (2021)] and [S. W. Hancock et al. , Phys. Rev. Lett. 127 , 193901 (2021)] claimed the OAM values which differ by a factor of 2 for circular STVPs. Here we resolve this controversy by showing that the result by Hancock et al. is correct for the total OAM, while the result by Bliokh describes the suitably defined intrinsic part of the OAM. The other, extrinsic part of the OAM originates from the fact that plane waves of the same amplitude but different frequencies in the pulse spectrum contain different densities of photons, which induces a transverse vortex-dependent shift of the photon centroid even in a STVP with symmetric energy-density distribution. We describe similar peculiarities of acoustic and quantum-relativistic (Klein-Gordon and arbitrary-spin) STVPs. In all cases, only the intrinsic OAM keeps a universal form independent of the details of the problem and similar to the OAM of monochromatic vortex beams. https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevA.107.L031501 ©2023 American Physical Society
Closed forms for spatiotemporal optical vortices and sagittal skyrmionic pulses

S. Vo,R. Gutiérrez-Cuevas,M.A. Alonso

2024-06-04

Abstract:Spatiotemporal optical vortices (STOVs) are short pulses that present a vortex whose axis is perpendicular to the main propagation direction. We present analytic expressions for these pulses that satisfy exactly Maxwell's equation, by applying appropriate differential operators to complex focus pulses with Poisson-like frequency spectrum. We also provide a simple ray picture for understanding the deformation of these pulses under propagation. Finally, we use these solutions to propose a type of pulse with sagittal skyrmionic polarization distribution covering all states of transverse polarization.

Optics
Comment on "Optical torque on small chiral particles in generic optical fields "

Manuel Nieto-Vesperinas

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1712.08808

2017-12-23

Optics

Abstract:We comment on mistakes and inaccuracies of a paper by Chen et al. concerning the optical torque from generic optical fields on dipolar chiral particles, i.e. on those whose scattering is fully described by the first electric, magnetic and magnetoelectric Mie coefficients.
Quantum theory of orbital angular momentum in spatiotemporal optical vortices

Pronoy Das,Sathwik Bharadwaj,Zubin Jacob

2024-03-25

Abstract:Spatiotemporal Optical Vortices (STOVs) are structured electromagnetic fields propagating in free space with phase singularities in the space-time domain. Depending on the tilt of the helical phase front, STOVs can carry both longitudinal and transverse orbital angular momentum (OAM). Although STOVs have gained significant interest in the recent years, the current understanding is limited to the semi-classical picture. Here, we develop a quantum theory for STOVs with an arbitrary tilt, extending beyond the paraxial limit. We demonstrate that quantum STOV states, such as Fock and coherent twisted photon pulses, display non-vanishing longitudinal OAM fluctuations that are absent in conventional monochromatic twisted pulses. We show that these quantum fluctuations exhibit a unique texture, i.e. a spatial distribution which can be used to experimentally isolate these quantum effects. Our findings represent a step towards the exploitation of quantum effects of structured light for various applications such as OAM-based encoding protocols and platforms to explore novel light-matter interaction in 2D material systems.

Optics,Quantum Physics
Comment on "Spatiotemporal torquing of light"

Miguel A. Porras

2024-03-18

Abstract:The recent paper Phys. Rev. X. 14, 011031 (

Optics
Erratum: Direct Mechanical Detection and Measurement of Wave-Matter Orbital Angular Momentum Transfer by Nondissipative Vortex Mode Conversion ]

B. Sanchez-Padilla,L. Jonusauskas,M. Malinauskas,R. Wunenburger,and E. Brasselet

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/physrevlett.132.079902

IF: 8.6

2024-02-15

Physical Review Letters

Abstract:Received 4 January 2024 © 2024 American Physical Society Physics Subject Headings (PhySH) Research Areas Acoustic wave phenomenaMechanical effects of light on material media General Physics

physics, multidisciplinary
Spatiotemporal Optical Vortices: Toward Tailoring Orbital Angular Momentum of Light in Full Space-Time

Wei Chen,Yuan Liu,Yan-Qing Lu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1021/acsphotonics.2c01524

IF: 7

2023-01-01

ACS Photonics

Abstract:Longitudinal orbital angular momentum (OAM) is a fundamental property of light that has been the subject of extensive research and applied to diverse important applications, such as optical tweezers, super-resolution imaging, and optical information processing. Recently, photons have been observed to possess transverse OAM, where the OAM vector is orthogonal to the direction of light propagation. As the carrier for this unique OAM, the spatiotemporal (ST) optical vortex has attracted considerable interest. Here, we provide a general overview of recent experimental and theoretical advances on such vortices, presenting their synthesis and measurement strategies, highlighting their nontrivial properties in linear propagation and interaction with nonlinear matter, and discussing the possible future trends and challenges.
Structured Ray-Wave Vector Vortex Beams in Multiple Degrees of Freedom from a Laser: Erratum

Yijie Shen,Xilin Yang,Darryl Naidoo,Xing Fu,Andrew Forbes

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1364/optica.414397

IF: 10.4

2020-01-01

Optica

Abstract:This erratum to Optica 7 , 820 ( 2020 ) OPTIC8 2334-2536 10.1364/OPTICA.382994 clarifies the origins of the supplementary material.
Spatiotemporal Torquing of Light

S. W. Hancock,S. Zahedpour,A. Goffin,H. M. Milchberg,S. W. Hancock,and H. M. Milchberg

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/physrevx.14.011031

2024-02-29

Physical Review X

Abstract:We demonstrate the controlled spatiotemporal transfer of transverse orbital angular momentum (OAM) to electromagnetic waves: the spatiotemporal torquing of light. This is a radically different situation from OAM transfer to longitudinal, spatially defined OAM light by stationary or slowly varying refractive-index structures such as phase plates or air turbulence. We show that net transverse OAM per photon can be spatiotemporally imparted to a light pulse only if (1) a transient phase perturbation is well overlapped with the pulse in spacetime, or (2) the pulse initially has nonzero transverse OAM density, and the perturbation removes energy from it. Physical insight is provided by the mechanical analogy of torquing a wheel or removing mass as it spins. Our OAM theory for spatiotemporal optical vortex (STOV) pulses [S. W. Hancock et al. , Phys. Rev. Lett. 127 , 193901 (2021)] correctly quantifies the light-matter interaction of our experiments and provides a spatiotemporal-torque-based explanation for the first measurement of STOVs [N. Jhajj et al. , Phys. Rev. X 6 , 031037 (2016)]. https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevX.14.011031 Published by the American Physical Society under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International license. Further distribution of this work must maintain attribution to the author(s) and the published article's title, journal citation, and DOI. Published by the American Physical Society

physics, multidisciplinary
Comment on “optical Orbital Angular Momentum from the Curl of Polarization”

Shaohui Yan,Baoli Yao,Ming Lei

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/physrevlett.106.189301

IF: 8.6

2011-01-01

Physical Review Letters

Abstract:A Comment on the Letter by Xi-Lin Wang et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 105, 253602 (2010). The authors of the Letter offer a Reply.Received 5 January 2011DOI:https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevLett.106.189301© 2011 American Physical Society
Numerical investigation on circular interference photoelectron momentum distributions induced by spatiotemporal optical vortex pulse

Yuge Deng Guizhong Zhang Kecheng Liu Wei Shi Jianquan Yao Key Lab of Optoelectronic Information Technology,Ministry of Education,College of Precision Instrument and Optoelectronics Engineering,Tianjin University,Tianjin,People's Republic of China

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/09500340.2024.2437052

IF: 1.3

2024-12-11

Journal of Modern Optics

Abstract:Using the strong field approximation theory, we conducted a detailed numerical investigation on the photoelectron momentum distributions (PMDs) arising from the ionization of hydrogen atoms by a circularly polarized spatiotemporal optical vortex (STOV) pulse. STOV pulses have a unique spatial structure and peculiar phase properties. Our simulations reveal that PMDs exhibit a complex interference structure characterized by circular momentum bands intertwined with intricate interference fringes. A thorough examination of the multi-photon process provides a comprehensive explanation for the circular momentum band formation. We develop an expression to elucidate their center momentum positions within the PMDs. Furthermore, we perform a detailed analysis of the fine interference fringes, attributing their origin to the singular phase of the STOV pulse. Despite their distinct manifestations, we infer that the circular momentum bands and fine interference fringes stem from the simultaneous dependence upon the space and time variables of the STOV phase.

optics
Spatiotemporal Differentiators Generating Optical Vortices with Transverse Orbital Angular Momentum and Detecting Sharp Change of Pulse Envelope

Junyi Huang,Jiahao Zhang,Tengfeng Zhu,Zhichao Ruan

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1002/lpor.202100357

2022-02-16

Abstract:Abstract As a new degree of freedom for optical manipulation, recently, spatiotemporal optical vortices (STOVs) carrying transverse orbital angular momentums have been experimentally demonstrated with pulse shapers. Here, a spatiotemporal differentiator is proposed to generate STOVs with transverse orbital angular momentum. In order to create phase singularity in the spatiotemporal domain, the spatiotemporal differentiator is designed by breaking spatial mirror symmetry. In contrast to pulse shapers, the device proposed here is a simple one‐dimensional periodic nanostructure and thus it is much more compact. For a normal incident pulse, the differentiator generates a transmitted STOV pulse with transverse orbital angular momentum. Furthermore, the interference of the generated STOVs can be used to detect the sharp changes of pulse envelopes, in both spatial and temporal dimensions.

physics, condensed matter,optics, applied
Comment on "On the Klein–Gordon oscillator in topologically charged Ellis–Bronnikov-type wormhole spacetime"

Paolo Amore,Francisco M. Fernández

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1140/epjp/s13360-024-05053-x

2024-03-16

The European Physical Journal Plus

Abstract:Our analysis of the results in a paper published recently in this journal shows that the authors failed to truncate the series that supposedly would yield the allowed energies of the bound states. Consequently, all the conclusions derived from their analytical expressions are incorrect.

physics, multidisciplinary
Spatiotemporal Acoustic Vortex Beams with Transverse Orbital Angular Momentum

Hao Ge,Shuai Liu,Xiang-Yuan Xu,Zi-Wei Long,Yuan Tian,Xiao-Ping Liu,Ming-Hui Lu,Yan-Feng Chen

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/physrevlett.131.014001

IF: 8.6

2023-07-08

Physical Review Letters

Abstract:Recently, the discovery of optical spatiotemporal (ST) vortex beams with transverse orbital angular momentum (OAM) has attracted increasing attention and is expected to extend the research scope and open new opportunities for practical applications of OAM states. The ST vortex beams are also applicable to other physical fields that involve wave phenomena, and here we develop the ST vortex concept in the field of acoustics and report the generation of Bessel-type ST acoustic vortex beams. The ST vortex beams are fully characterized using the scalar approach for the pressure field and the vector approach for the velocity field. We further investigate the transverse spreading effect and construct ST vortex beams with an ellipse-shaped spectrum to reduce the spreading effect. We also experimentally demonstrated the orthogonality relations between ST vortex beams with different charges. Our study successfully demonstrates the versatility of the acoustic system for exploring and discovering spatiotemporally structured waves, inspiring further investigation of exotic wave physics. https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevLett.131.014001 © 2023 American Physical Society

physics, multidisciplinary
Generation of robust spatiotemporal optical vortices with transverse orbital angular momentum beyond 10^2

Wei Chen,Wang Zhang,Yuan Liu,Fan-Chao Meng,John M. Dudley,Yan-Qing Lu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-022-31623-7

2021-01-01

Abstract:Recently, photons have been observed to possess transverse orbital angular momentum (OAM); however, it is unclear as whether they can hold a transverse OAM higher than 1. Here, we theoretically and experimentally demonstrate that high-order spatiotemporal Bessel optical vortices (STBOVs) can stably carry transverse OAM even beyond 10^2. Through the inverse design of the spiral phase, an STBOV of any order can be controllably generated using a 4f pulse shaper. In contrast to conventional longitudinal OAM, the vector direction of the transverse OAM can be distinguished by the unique time-symmetrical evolution of STBOVs. More interestingly, the stability of STBOVs improves with their increasing orders owing to enhanced space-time coupling, making these beams particularly suitable for the generation of ultra-high transverse OAM. Our work paves the way for further research and application of this unique OAM of photons.
Comment on ``The Effect of Vacuum Polarization ... in Strongly Magnetized Plasmas'' by Ozel (<a class="link-https" data-arxiv-id="astro-ph/0203449" href="https://arxiv.org/abs/astro-ph/0203449">astro-ph/0203449</a>)

Dong Lai,Wynn C.G. Ho

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.astro-ph/0204187

2002-04-11

Abstract:We have recently shown that in a highly magnetized neutron star atmospheric plasma, vacuum polarization can induce resonant conversion of photon polarization modes via a mechanism analogous to MSW neutrino oscillation. In a recent paper Ozel has dismissed this mode conversion effect as ``mistakes''. Here we explain why our arguments/calculations of this effect are correct.

Astrophysics

Comment on "Mode Structure and Orbital Angular Momentum of Spatiotemporal Optical Vortex (STOV) Pulses"

Clarification of the transverse orbital angular momentum of spatiotemporal optical vortices

Quantized Optical Orbital Angular Momentum Precession and Nutation in a Twisted Light

Spatio-temporal optical vortices: principles of description and basic properties

Orbital angular momentum of optical, acoustic, and quantum-mechanical spatiotemporal vortex pulses

Closed forms for spatiotemporal optical vortices and sagittal skyrmionic pulses

Comment on "Optical torque on small chiral particles in generic optical fields "

Quantum theory of orbital angular momentum in spatiotemporal optical vortices

Comment on "Spatiotemporal torquing of light"

Erratum: Direct Mechanical Detection and Measurement of Wave-Matter Orbital Angular Momentum Transfer by Nondissipative Vortex Mode Conversion ]

Spatiotemporal Optical Vortices: Toward Tailoring Orbital Angular Momentum of Light in Full Space-Time

Structured Ray-Wave Vector Vortex Beams in Multiple Degrees of Freedom from a Laser: Erratum

Spatiotemporal Torquing of Light

Comment on “optical Orbital Angular Momentum from the Curl of Polarization”

Numerical investigation on circular interference photoelectron momentum distributions induced by spatiotemporal optical vortex pulse

Spatiotemporal Differentiators Generating Optical Vortices with Transverse Orbital Angular Momentum and Detecting Sharp Change of Pulse Envelope

Comment on "On the Klein–Gordon oscillator in topologically charged Ellis–Bronnikov-type wormhole spacetime"

Spatiotemporal Acoustic Vortex Beams with Transverse Orbital Angular Momentum

Generation of robust spatiotemporal optical vortices with transverse orbital angular momentum beyond 10^2

Comment on ``The Effect of Vacuum Polarization ... in Strongly Magnetized Plasmas'' by Ozel (<a class="link-https" data-arxiv-id="astro-ph/0203449" href="https://arxiv.org/abs/astro-ph/0203449">astro-ph/0203449</a>)