R. R. S. Oliveira
Abstract:In this comment, we showed that the Dirac equation in the screw dislocation space-time also carries a term that represents the torsion of such topological defect, given by $K_\mu$. Therefore, the Dirac equation worked by Wang et al. is incomplete since such a term was ignored in your equation (what cannot happen). In other words, it is only possible to work with the Dirac equation in the form presented by Wang et al. if the space-time is torsion-free, which is obviously not the case.
Mesoscale and Nanoscale Physics,General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology,Quantum Physics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is whether the torsion term that describes this topological defect is completely included in the Dirac equation in the spacetime context of screw dislocation. Specifically:
1. **Background and Problem Statement**:
- In previous research, Wang et al. studied the spin current caused by topological screw dislocation and cosmic dispiration by extending the Drude model and concluded that the spin - related force is changed by the non - trivial geometric structure.
- However, Oliveira pointed out that the Dirac equation used by Wang et al. ignored the torsion term \( K_\mu \) when describing the screw - dislocation spacetime, which makes their equation incomplete in the presence of torsion.
2. **Core Problem**:
- Oliveira emphasized that in the screw - dislocation spacetime, the Dirac equation should include an additional term to describe the torsion of this topological defect. The specific form of the Dirac equation is as follows:
\[
[i\gamma^\mu(x)\nabla_\mu(x) - m]\Psi = 0
\]
where
\[
\nabla_\mu(x) = \partial_\mu(x) + \Gamma_\mu(x) + K_\mu(x)
\]
Here \( \nabla_\mu(x) \) is the covariant derivative, \( \partial_\mu \) is the usual partial derivative, \( \Gamma_\mu(x) \) is the spinor connection, and \( K_\mu(x) \) is the contortion tensor, which depends on the torsion tensor.
3. **Key Findings**:
- Oliveira pointed out that Wang et al. ignored the \( K_\mu \) term, so their Dirac equation is only valid in the absence of torsion, which is impossible in the screw - dislocation spacetime. This means that the equation of Wang et al. is incomplete and cannot accurately describe the influence of screw dislocation on the spin current.
4. **Conclusion**:
- Oliveira's comment aims to correct this oversight and emphasizes that when dealing with the Dirac equation in the screw - dislocation spacetime, the \( K_\mu \) term that describes torsion must be included to ensure the integrity and accuracy of the theory.
In conclusion, the main purpose of this paper is to point out and correct the key term omitted by Wang et al. when dealing with the Dirac equation in the screw - dislocation spacetime, thereby ensuring the rigor and correctness of the theory.