Nuclear elastic scattering of protons below 250 MeV in FLUKA v4-4.0 and its role in single-event-upset production in electronics

Alexandra-Gabriela Serban,Andrea Coronetti,Ruben Garcia Alia,Francesc Salvat Pujol
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cpc.2024.109276
2023-12-20
Abstract:FLUKA is among the general-purpose codes for the Monte Carlo simulation of radiation transport that are routinely employed to estimate the production of single-event-upsets (SEUs) in commercial static random access memories (SRAMs) exposed to radiation. Earlier studies concerning the production of SEUs in commercial SRAMs under proton irradiation revealed very good agreement between experimental measurements and FLUKA estimates of the SEU production cross section for proton energies above 20-30 MeV. However, at lower proton energies, where the cross section for SEU production in such low-critical-charge components increases drastically, a FLUKA underestimation of up to two orders of magnitude was observed. Preliminary analyses indicated that this underestimation was in great measure due to the lack of nuclear elastic scattering of protons below 10 MeV in FLUKA up to version 4-3.4. To overcome this limitation, a new model for the nuclear elastic scattering of protons has been developed, combining partial-wave analyses and experimental angular distributions. This newly developed model has been included in FLUKA v4-4.0, and leads to an order-of-magnitude improvement in the agreement between FLUKA and experimental cross sections for the production of SEUs in SRAMs under proton irradiation in the 1-10 MeV energy domain.
Computational Physics,Nuclear Experiment,Accelerator Physics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is the underestimation of the single - event upset (SEU) production cross - section by the FLUKA simulation software under low - energy proton (1 - 10 MeV) irradiation. Specifically, the FLUKA v4 - 3.4 version has deficiencies in handling proton - nucleus elastic scattering below 10 MeV, resulting in a difference of up to two orders of magnitude between its prediction of the SEU production cross - section of commercial static random - access memory (SRAM) under low - energy proton irradiation and the experimental measurement results. To overcome this limitation, the author developed a new proton - nucleus elastic scattering model and integrated it into the FLUKA v4 - 4.0 version to improve the accuracy of SEU production cross - section prediction under low - energy proton irradiation. ### Main problems 1. **Underestimation of SEU production cross - section under low - energy proton irradiation**: - In the energy range of 1 - 10 MeV, proton - nucleus elastic scattering makes a significant contribution to SEU production, but the FLUKA v4 - 3.4 version lacks the modeling of this mechanism. - This leads to a large deviation between the FLUKA v4 - 3.4 prediction of the SEU production cross - section and the experimental data. 2. **Limitations of the existing model**: - The proton - nucleus elastic scattering model in the FLUKA v4 - 3.4 version is inactive in the low - energy region (< 10 MeV). - Even at higher energies (> 10 MeV), the model's description of large - angle scattering is not accurate enough, resulting in a large prediction error of the SEU production cross - section. ### Solutions 1. **Development of a new model**: - A new proton - nucleus elastic scattering model was developed, which combines partial - wave analysis and experimental angular distribution data. - The new model can more accurately describe the nuclear elastic scattering process of low - energy protons, especially large - angle scattering in the energy range of 1 - 10 MeV. 2. **Implementation of the model**: - The optical potential model (OPM) was used to describe the interaction between protons and target nuclei, and a set of differential cross - section (DXS) databases was generated. - By fitting a parameterized expression (containing 7 parameters), the DXS in the database was simplified into an effective analytical form to reduce memory requirements. - A numerical sampling algorithm was implemented to simulate proton - nucleus elastic scattering events. 3. **Performance evaluation**: - The new model prediction results of FLUKA v4 - 4.0 were compared with the experimental data, and the results showed that the prediction accuracy of the new model for the SEU production cross - section under low - energy proton irradiation was improved by about one order of magnitude. ### Conclusion By introducing a new proton - nucleus elastic scattering model, FLUKA v4 - 4.0 significantly improves the prediction accuracy of the SEU production cross - section under low - energy proton irradiation and solves the underestimation problem existing in the FLUKA v4 - 3.4 version. This improvement is of great significance for evaluating the reliability of electronic devices in a radiation environment.