Solid state phase transformation kinetics in Zr-base alloys

A. R. Massih,L. O. Jernkvist

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-021-86308-w

2021-04-01

Abstract:We present a kinetic model for solid state phase transformation (alpha<-->beta) of common zirconium alloys used as fuel cladding material in light water reactors. The model computes the relative amounts of beta or alpha phase fraction as a function of time or temperature in the alloys. The model accounts for the influence of excess oxygen (due to oxidation) and hydrogen concentration (due to hydrogen pickup) on phase transformation kinetics. Two variants of the model denoted by A and B are presented. Model A is suitable for simulation of laboratory experiments in which the heating/cooling rate is constant and is prescribed. Model B is more generic. We compare the results of our model computations, for both A and B variants, with accessible experimental data reported in the literature covering heating/cooling rates of up to 100 K/s. The results of our comparison are satisfactory, especially for model A. Our model B is intended for implementation in fuel rod behavior computer programs, applicable to a reactor accident situation, in which the Zr-based fuel cladding may go through alpha<-->beta phase transformation.

Materials Science

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem this paper attempts to address is the establishment of a dynamic model to describe the behavior of zirconium-based alloys during the solid-state phase transformation (α⇌β). Specifically, the model aims to calculate the proportion of β or α phase in the alloy as a function of time and temperature, and to consider the impact of excess oxygen and hydrogen concentration on the phase transformation kinetics during the oxidation process.

### Background and Objectives
Zirconium-based alloys are widely used as fuel cladding materials in light water reactors due to their low neutron absorption cross-section and good corrosion resistance. These alloys exist in two stable crystal structures in the solid state: the α phase (hexagonal close-packed) at low temperatures and the β phase (body-centered cubic) at high temperatures. Understanding the phase transformation process is crucial for understanding the material's performance under different conditions, especially in the event of a reactor accident where the fuel cladding may undergo α⇌β phase transformation.

### Model Description
The paper proposes two model variants, referred to as Model A and Model B:
- **Model A**: Suitable for laboratory experiments where the heating/cooling rate is constant and known. Model A considers the effect of heating/cooling rate on the phase transformation kinetics.
- **Model B**: More general, suitable for reactor accident simulations where the temperature history may be unknown and uneven. Model B does not explicitly depend on the heating/cooling rate.

### Experimental Data
The paper reviews a large amount of published experimental data, including the phase transformation behavior of different zirconium-based alloys under various conditions. This data covers phase transformation behavior at different heating/cooling rates (up to 100 K/s) and the effect of excess oxygen and hydrogen concentration on the phase transformation.

### Results and Comparison
- **Model A**: Compared with experimental data, Model A performs well in describing phase transformation behavior, especially under constant heating/cooling rates.
- **Model B**: Although Model B slightly underestimates in some cases (e.g., heating at 100 K/s), it generally agrees well with experimental data and can qualitatively describe the trend of α⇌β phase transformation.

### Application Example
The paper also demonstrates the application of Model B in simulating the temperature history of fuel cladding under Loss-of-Coolant Accident (LOCA) conditions in a Pressurized Water Reactor (PWR). The results show that Model B can effectively predict phase transformation kinetics, although the impact of high-temperature oxidation is relatively small.

### Conclusion
By establishing a dynamic model, this paper provides a powerful tool for understanding and predicting the phase transformation behavior of zirconium-based alloys under different conditions, particularly suitable for reactor safety analysis and accident simulations.