Simultaneous elastic shape optimization for a domain splitting in bone tissue engineering

Patrick Dondl,Patrina S. P. Poh,Martin Rumpf,Stefan Simon
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1098/rspa.2018.0718
2018-09-20
Abstract:This paper deals with the simulateneous optimization of a subset $\mathcal{O}_0$ of some domain $\Omega$ and its complement $\mathcal{O}_1 = \Omega \setminus \overline{\mathcal{O}}_0$ both considered as separate elastic objects subject to a set of loading scenarios. If one asks for a configuration which minimizes the maximal elastic cost functional both phases compete for space since elastic shapes usually get mechanically more stable when being enlarged. Such a problem arises in biomechanics where a bioresorbable polymer scaffold is implanted in place of lost bone tissue and in a regeneration phase new bone tissue grows in the scaffold complement via osteogenesis. In fact, the polymer scaffold should be mechanically stable to bear loading in the early stage regeneration phase and at the same time the new bone tissue grown in the complement of this scaffold should as well bear the loading. Here, this optimal subdomain splitting problem with appropriate elastic cost functionals is introduced and existence of optimal two phase configurations is established for a regularized formulation. Furthermore, based on a phase field approximation a finite element discretization is derived. Numerical experiments are presented for the design of optimal periodic scaffold microstructure.
Numerical Analysis
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is how to design the optimal microstructure of bio - absorbable polymer scaffolds through elastic shape optimization in bone tissue engineering. Specifically, the core of the problem lies in how to divide two sub - domains \(O_0\) and \(O_1\) in a given domain \(\Omega\), so that these two sub - domains can bear mechanical loads respectively and maximize their overall elastic properties under different loading conditions. ### Specific description of the problem 1. **Background and application**: - In bone tissue engineering, when bone loss occurs, a bio - absorbable polymer scaffold (such as polycaprolactone, PCL) is usually implanted to provide initial mechanical support and promote the growth of new bone tissue. - The scaffold needs to provide sufficient mechanical stability in the early stage, and at the same time, the newly generated bone tissue also needs to be able to bear mechanical loads. - Therefore, it is necessary to optimize the spatial distribution of the scaffold and the new bone tissue to ensure that both can effectively bear mechanical loads. 2. **Mathematical modeling**: - Divide a given domain \(\Omega\subset\mathbb{R}^d\) into two sub - domains \(O_0\) and \(O_1\), where \(O_0\) represents the polymer scaffold and \(O_1=\Omega\setminus O_0\) represents the newly generated bone tissue. - Each sub - domain follows the laws of linear elastic mechanics and has different elastic tensors \(C_0\) and \(C_1\). - The goal is to find an optimal partitioning scheme so that the maximum value of the elastic cost functions of the two sub - domains is minimized under multiple loading conditions. 3. **Optimization objective**: - The elastic cost function \(J_m[\chi_m]\) is defined based on the stored elastic energy \(E_m\), which reflects the stiffness of each sub - domain under different loading conditions. - The overall objective function \(J[\chi]\) is the maximum value of the cost functions of the two sub - domains: \[ J[\chi]=\max(J_0[\chi], J_1[1 - \chi]) \] - The key to this optimization problem is the competition between the two sub - domains: as the sub - domains expand, their mechanical stability usually increases, but they also occupy more space. 4. **Numerical methods**: - To deal with this complex optimization problem, the author introduced the phase - field approximation and finite - element discretization methods. - The phase - field model replaces the characteristic function \(\chi\) with a continuous phase - field function \(v\) and regularizes the problem by adding an interface energy term. - Finally, the optimal microstructures under different material parameters and loading conditions were verified through numerical experiments. ### Summary The main goal of this paper is to design the optimal microstructure of bio - absorbable polymer scaffolds through elastic shape optimization to ensure that both the scaffold and the newly generated bone tissue can effectively bear mechanical loads during the regeneration process. The solution to this problem is of great significance for improving the treatment effect in bone tissue engineering.