Abstract:Equations are about more than computing physical quantities or constructing formal models; they are also about understanding. The conceptual systems physicists use to think about nature are made from many different resources, formal and not, working together and inextricably linked. By blending mathematical forms and physical intuition, physicists breathe meaning into the equations they use. In contrast, in physics class, novice students often treat mathematics as only a calculational tool, isolating it from their rich knowledge of the physical world. We are interested in cases where students break that pattern by reading, manipulating, and building equations meaningfully rather than purely formally. To find examples of this and explore the diversity of ways students combine formal and intuitive resources, we conducted problem-solving interviews with students in an introductory physics for life sciences class. During the interviews, we scaffolded student use of strategies which call for both formal and intuitive reasoning, such as "examine the extreme cases". We use the analytic framework of epistemic games to model how students used the strategies and how they accessed problem-solving resources, and we present evidence that novice students using these strategies accessed more expert-like conceptual systems than those typically described in problem-solving literature. They blended physical intuition with mathematical symbolic templates, reconceptualized the nature of equations, and distinguished similar functional forms. Once introduced to a strategy, students applied it to new scenarios and found new types of uses for it, acknowledging it as a useful, general purpose problem-solving technique. Our data suggests that these strategies can potentially help novice students learn to develop and apply their physical intuition more effectively.

The Use of Epistemic Distancing to Create a Safe Space to Sensemake in Introductory Physics Tutorials

Making Space to Sensemake: Epistemic Distancing in Small Group Physics Discussions

'Because math': Epistemological stance or defusing social tension in QM?

The Dynamics of Students' Behaviors and Reasoning during Collaborative Physics Tutorial Sessions

Navigating Socio-Emotional Risk through Comfort-Building in a Physics Teaching Community of Practice: A Case Study

Instructing nontraditional physics labs: Toward responsiveness to student epistemic framing

Epistemic stances toward group work in learning physics: Interactions between epistemology and social dynamics in a collaborative problem solving context

Sensemaking and Scientific Modeling: Intertwined processes analyzed in the context of physics problem solving

Rethinking the division of labor between tutorial writers and instructors with respect to fostering equitable team dynamics

Dynamics of Productive Confirmation Framing in an Introductory Lab

Language of Physics, Language of Math: Disciplinary Culture and Dynamic Epistemology

Blending physical knowledge with mathematical form in physics problem solving

Creating a More Equitable Introductory Physics Classroom Through Invitational Phrasing in Question Solicitation

Teacher Noticing and Shifting of Student Epistemic Framing

Analyzing students collaboratively solving spherical unit vector problems in upper level E and M through a lens of shared resources

Theoretical exploration of task features that facilitate student sensemaking in physics

Case Study of a Successful Learner's Epistemological Framings of Quantum Mechanics.

Potential relationship of epistemic games to group dynamics and learning orientations towards physics problem solving

Sustaining educational reforms in introductory physics

Characterizing active learning environments in physics using network analysis and COPUS observations

Brief, embedded, spontaneous metacognitive talk indicates thinking like a physicist