Abstract:Researchers generally agree that physics experts use mathematics in a way that blends mathematical knowledge with physics intuition. However, the use of mathematics in physics education has traditionally tended to focus more on the computational aspect (manipulating mathematical operations to get numerical solutions) to the detriment of building conceptual understanding and physics intuition. Several solutions to this problem have been suggested; some authors have suggested building conceptual understanding before mathematics is introduced, while others have argued for the inseparability of the two, claiming instead that mathematics and conceptual physics need to be taught simultaneously. Although there is a body of work looking into how students employ mathematical reasoning when working with equations, the specifics of how physics experts use mathematics blended with physics intuition remain relatively underexplored. In this paper, we describe some components of this blending, by analyzing how physicists perform the rearrangement of a specific equation in cosmology. Our data consist of five consecutive forms of rearrangement of the equation, as observed in three separate higher education cosmology courses. This rearrangement was analyzed from a conceptual reasoning perspective using Sherin's framework of symbolic forms. Our analysis clearly demonstrates how the number of potential symbolic forms associated with each subsequent rearrangement of the equation decreases as we move from line to line. Drawing on this result, we suggest an underlying mechanism for how physicists reason with equations. This mechanism seems to consist of three components: narrowing down meaning potential, moving aspects between the background and the foreground and purposefully transforming the equation according to the discipline's questions of interest. In the discussion section we highlight the potential that our work has for generalizability and how being aware of the components of this underlying mechanism can potentially affect physics teachers' practice when using mathematics in the physics classroom.

'Because math': Epistemological stance or defusing social tension in QM?

Epistemic stances toward group work in learning physics: Interactions between epistemology and social dynamics in a collaborative problem solving context

Making Space to Sensemake: Epistemic Distancing in Small Group Physics Discussions

Case Study of a Successful Learner's Epistemological Framings of Quantum Mechanics.

Student reasoning about quantum mechanics while working with physical experiments

The Use of Epistemic Distancing to Create a Safe Space to Sensemake in Introductory Physics Tutorials

The Dynamics of Students' Behaviors and Reasoning during Collaborative Physics Tutorial Sessions

Perspectives in Quantum Physics: Epistemological, Ontological and Pedagogical. An investigation into student and expert perspectives on the physical interpretation of quantum mechanics, with implications for modern physics instruction

Should we trade off higher-level mathematics for abstraction to improve student understanding of quantum mechanics?

Language of Physics, Language of Math: Disciplinary Culture and Dynamic Epistemology

Framing Difficulties in Quantum Mechanics

Towards a better understanding of conceptual difficulties in introductory quantum physics courses

Blending physical knowledge with mathematical form in physics problem solving

Mathematical sense making of quantum phenomena using Dirac notation: its effect on secondary school students' functional thinking about photons

Rearranging Equations to Develop Physics Reasoning

Students' Experience of Cultural Differences Between Mathematics and Physics

Analyzing Problem Solving Using Math in Physics: Epistemological Framing via Warrants

Potential relationship of epistemic games to group dynamics and learning orientations towards physics problem solving

A Framework for Understanding the Patterns of Student Reasoning Difficulties in Quantum Mechanics

Student reasoning about sources of experimental measurement uncertainty in quantum versus classical mechanics

Refined Characterization of Student Perspectives on Quantum Physics