Abstract:Previous research has suggested that making classrooms more active and student centered improves learning, and this usually involves encouraging student talk in the classroom. However, the majority of students remain silent during whole-class discussions, and men's voices are more likely to be heard in science classrooms. Previous interview studies and quantitative studies have discussed the role instructors play in encouraging or discouraging participation, the weight students put into the fear of negative evaluation, and other factors. However, interview studies on the experiences of college students in the sciences, specifically, are lacking. Thus, we conducted a qualitative interview study to investigate students' experiences deciding whether to participate verbally in class, focusing on students recruited from science classrooms. We analyzed the data using an inductive approach and found three main themes: (1) A wide variety of external factors impact students' decision to participate, including instructor characteristics and choices, peer influences, and course material characteristics; (2) Students weigh these factors in complex ways, and this internal calculus varies by student; and (3) Women put greater emphasis on fearing peer judgment, and men may be more motivated by course material considerations. Most of the external factors we identified as important for student participation have been described previously, and we validate that previous literature. We add to the literature by a more complex discussion of how students weigh these different factors and how complex the classroom ecosystem can be. We end by framing our results within the Expectancy Value Theory of motivation, discussing limitations, and providing implications for science college instructors to promote broad and equitable participation.

Creating a More Equitable Introductory Physics Classroom Through Invitational Phrasing in Question Solicitation

Infusing Equity, Diversity, and Inclusion Throughout Our Physics Curriculum: (Re)defining What It Means to Be a Physicist

Group Dynamics in Inquiry-based Labs: Gender Inequities and the Efficacy of Partner Agreements

Instructing nontraditional physics labs: Toward responsiveness to student epistemic framing

Do female physics students benefit from informal physics programs they facilitate?

Breaking Barriers: Investigating Gender Dynamics in Introductory Physics Lab Classes

Blogging in the physics classroom: A research-based approach to shaping students' attitudes towards physics

To participate or not to participate? A qualitative investigation of students' complex motivations for verbal classroom participation

Sustaining educational reforms in introductory physics

Developing Peer Instruction questions for quantitative problems for an upper-division astronomy course

Inquiry-Based Teaching in the College Classroom: The Nontraditional Student

Flipping the Large-Enrollment Introductory Physics Classroom

Importance of accounting for student identities and intersectionality for creating equitable and inclusive physics learning environments

"Curious Is as Curious Does": Fostering Question-Asking in a Sino-Foreign Engineering School—A Case Study

An equity investigation of attitudinal shifts in introductory physics

Positive attitudinal shifts and a narrowing gender gap: Do expertlike attitudes correlate to higher learning gains for women in the physics classroom?

Sense of agency, gender, and students' perception in open-ended physics labs

From a systematic investigation of faculty-produced Think-Pair-Share questions to frameworks for characterizing and developing fluency-inspiring activities

An equitable and effective approach to introductory mechanics

Enhancing Curiosity Using Interactive Simulations Combined with Real-Time Formative Assessment Facilitated by Open-Format Questions on Tablet Computers

Restructuring physics labs to cultivate sense of student agency