Abstract:Equations are about more than computing physical quantities or constructing formal models; they are also about understanding. The conceptual systems physicists use to think about nature are made from many different resources, formal and not, working together and inextricably linked. By blending mathematical forms and physical intuition, physicists breathe meaning into the equations they use. In contrast, in physics class, novice students often treat mathematics as only a calculational tool, isolating it from their rich knowledge of the physical world. We are interested in cases where students break that pattern by reading, manipulating, and building equations meaningfully rather than purely formally. To find examples of this and explore the diversity of ways students combine formal and intuitive resources, we conducted problem-solving interviews with students in an introductory physics for life sciences class. During the interviews, we scaffolded student use of strategies which call for both formal and intuitive reasoning, such as "examine the extreme cases". We use the analytic framework of epistemic games to model how students used the strategies and how they accessed problem-solving resources, and we present evidence that novice students using these strategies accessed more expert-like conceptual systems than those typically described in problem-solving literature. They blended physical intuition with mathematical symbolic templates, reconceptualized the nature of equations, and distinguished similar functional forms. Once introduced to a strategy, students applied it to new scenarios and found new types of uses for it, acknowledging it as a useful, general purpose problem-solving technique. Our data suggests that these strategies can potentially help novice students learn to develop and apply their physical intuition more effectively.

Brief, embedded, spontaneous metacognitive talk indicates thinking like a physicist

Oersted Lecture 2013: How should we think about how our students think?

Introducing students to the culture of physics: Explicating elements of the hidden curriculum

Expounding on physics -- A phenomenographic study of physicists talking of their physics

Blending physical knowledge with mathematical form in physics problem solving

Language of Physics, Language of Math: Disciplinary Culture and Dynamic Epistemology

Becoming a Physicist: The Roles of Research, Mindsets, and Milestones in upper-division student perceptions

The role of context and culture in teaching physics: The implication of disciplinary differences

Infusing Equity, Diversity, and Inclusion Throughout Our Physics Curriculum: (Re)defining What It Means to Be a Physicist

What we talk about when we talk about physics problem solving

Making expert processes visible: how and why theorists use assumptions and analogies in their research

Effect of pressure on the superconducting transition temperature of doped and neutron-damaged MgB2

Towards a Generalized Assessment of Computational Thinking for Introductory Physics Students

Student evaluation of more or better experimental data in classical and quantum mechanics

From a systematic investigation of faculty-produced Think-Pair-Share questions to frameworks for characterizing and developing fluency-inspiring activities

Using conceptual metaphor and functional grammar to explore how language used in physics affects student learning

Are we teaching students to think like scientists?

Using disciplinary perspectives to refine conceptions of the "real world"

Physicality, Modeling and Making in a Computational Physics Class

Instructing nontraditional physics labs: Toward responsiveness to student epistemic framing

Perspectives in Quantum Physics: Epistemological, Ontological and Pedagogical. An investigation into student and expert perspectives on the physical interpretation of quantum mechanics, with implications for modern physics instruction