Thermodynamic Stability of Co-Al-W L12 γ'

James E. Saal,Chris Wolverton
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.actamat.2013.01.004
2012-10-04
Abstract:Co-based superalloys in the Co-Al-W system exhibit coherent L12 Co3(Al,W) \gamma' precipitates in an fcc Co \gamma matrix, analogous to Ni3Al in Ni-based systems. Unlike Ni3Al however, experimental observations of Co3(Al,W) suggest that it is not a stable phase at 1173K. Here, we perform an extensive series of density functional theory (DFT) calculations of the \gamma' Co3(Al,W) phase stability, including point defect energetics and finite-temperature contributions. We first confirm and extend previous DFT calculations of the metastability of L12 Co3(Al0.5W0.5) \gamma' at 0K with respect to HCP Co, B2 CoAl, and D019 Co3W using the special quasi-random structure (SQS) approach to describe the Al/W solid solution, employing several exchange/correlation functionals, structures with varying degrees of disorder, and newly developed larger SQS. We expand the validity of this conclusion by considering the formation of antisite and vacancy point defects, predicting defect formation energies similar in magnitude to Ni3Al. However, in contrast to the Ni3Al system, we find that substituting Co on Al sites is thermodynamically favorable at 0K, consistent with experimental observation of Co excess and Al deficiency in \gamma' with respect to the Co3(Al0.5W0.5) composition. Lastly, we consider vibrational, electronic, and magnetic contributions to the free energy, finding that they promote the stability of \gamma', making the phase thermodynamically competitive with the convex hull at elevated temperature. Surprisingly, this is due to the relatively small finite-temperature contributions of one of the \gamma' decomposition products, B2 CoAl, effectively destabilizing the Co, CoAl, and Co3W three phase mixture, thus stabilizing the \gamma' phase.
Materials Science
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is related to the thermodynamic stability of the L1₂Co₃(Al,W) γ' - phase in the Co - Al - W system. Specifically, the research aims to explore the following aspects: 1. **Stability of the γ' - phase at 0K**: Verify through density functional theory (DFT) calculations whether the L1₂Co₃(Al₀.₅W₀.₅) γ' - phase is metastable at 0K relative to other stable phases (such as HCP Co, B2 CoAl, and D0₁₉Co₃W). According to existing experimental observations, the Co₃(Al,W) γ' - phase does not seem to be a stable phase at 1173K, so theoretical calculations are required to confirm this phenomenon. 2. **Effect of point defects on stability**: Study the influence of antisite defects and vacancy defects on the stability of the γ' - phase. In particular, examine the energy change of Co atoms substituting for Al sites to explain the phenomena of Co excess and Al deficiency observed in experiments. 3. **Free - energy contributions at finite temperatures**: Consider the effects of vibrational, electronic excitation, and magnetic effects on the stability of the γ' - phase at high temperatures. These effects may influence the relative stability of the γ' - phase with respect to other competing phases, especially under high - temperature conditions around 1200K. ### Formula Summary - **Formation energy at 0K**: \[ \Delta E(Co_xAl_yW_z)=E(Co_xAl_yW_z)-\sum m\mu_m \] where \(E(Co_xAl_yW_z)\) is the total ground - state energy of the CoₓAlᵧWₙ compound obtained from DFT calculations, and \(\mu_m\) is the chemical potential of Co, Al, and W. - **Free - energy contributions at finite temperatures**: \[ \Delta F_j^{Stab}[T]=F_j(Co_3(Al_{0.5}W_{0.5}))[T]-\sum m\mu_m^j[T] \] where \(F_j(Co_3(Al_{0.5}W_{0.5}))\) is the contribution of physical effect \(j\) to the free energy of L1₂Co₃(Al₀.₅W₀.₅), and \(\mu_m^j\) is the change in chemical potential caused by physical effect \(j\). - **Defect formation energy**: \[ \Delta E_{Defect}(XY)=E(Defect)-E(Pristine)-\sum m\mu_m \] where \(E(Defect)\) is the supercell energy containing point defects, and \(E(Pristine)\) is the energy of the perfect structure. ### Main Findings - At 0K, the L1₂Co₃(Al₀.₅W₀.₅) γ' - phase is metastable relative to HCP Co, B2 CoAl, and D0₁₉Co₃W, and its formation energy is 66 meV/atom higher than the convex hull. - Point - defect analysis shows that Co substitution for Al sites is thermodynamically favorable, which is consistent with the experimentally observed Co excess and Al deficiency. - Vibrational, electronic excitation, and magnetic effects have a stabilizing effect on the free energy of the γ' - phase, significantly reducing its metastability at 1200K from 66 meV/atom to 11 meV/atom. In summary, this study, through detailed DFT calculations and finite - temperature - effect analysis, reveals the thermodynamic stability of the γ' - phase in the Co - Al - W system and explains some of the phenomena observed in experiments.