Abstract:The extensive time and computational effort are primary challenges in nonlinear dynamic analysis of tunnel-form concrete systems. These challenges lead engineers to resort to simpler, pushover-based analyses, inherently based on estimating the seismic performance point of the system. Technical literature review indicates that no study has yet rigorously evaluated the accuracy of existing methods for estimating the performance point of tunnel-form systems. To eliminate potential ambiguities, in this study, the seismic performance point of the system under design basis earthquake (with a 475-year return period) has been calculated using three different methods (i.e., displacement coefficient, capacity spectrum, and displacement amplification factor), and compared with the results of accurate nonlinear time-history analysis. In the range of 5-, 7-, and 10-story models studied, the results indicate the inefficiency and insufficiency of the mentioned methods. Investigations reveal that while the capacity spectrum method provides better results, but its process is lengthy, and the displacement coefficient method significantly overestimates the performance point (with more than 80 % error). It was also evident that the displacement amplification factor underestimates the performance point and contradicts the direction of confidence. Based on observations, the use of all three methods for the tunnel-form system requires modifications. The calculated values of effective damping ratio for the tunnel-form system explicitly indicate type A behavior according to the ATC-40 classification. By presenting this parameter in a multi-level format, the shortcomings of both capacity spectrum and displacement coefficient methods are easily addressed. Referring to the results, the calculated value of the displacement amplification factor in the system exceeds the recommended value by the seismic design code, and by adjusting it, satisfactory responses can be obtained in the method based on the displacement amplification factor. Finally, introducing the "probable performance interval" parameter, recommending its use instead of the "performance point" parameter in assessments by pushover analysis is suggested. This parameter is applicable with all three mentioned methods and has been introduced in this study as a desirable factor in compensating for inherent uncertainties related to future earthquakes.

Direct scaling of residual displacements for bilinear and pinching oscillators

Inelastic Displacement Amplification Factor for Ductile Structures with Constant Strength Reduction Factor

Estimation of inelastic displacement ratio spectrum for existing RC structures via displacement response spectrum

Dynamic P-△ Effects on Seismic Force Modification Factors

A Direct Displacement-Based Design Procedure for Base-Isolated Building Structures with Lead Rubber Bearings (Lrbs)

Seismic Force Modification Factor for Ductile Structures

Inelastic Yielding Strength Demand Coefficient Spectra

Estimation of peak displacements in steel structures through dimensional analysis and the efficiency of alternative ground-motion time and length scales

Probability-based analytical model for predicting the post-earthquake residual deformation of SDOF systems

CONSTANT DUCTILITY INELASTIC DISPLACEMENT SPECTRUM AND ITS APPLICATION

Residual Displacement Responses of Structures Subjected to Near-Fault Pulse-Like Ground Motions

Probabilistic inelastic displacement demand estimation for SDOF self-centering viscous systems subjected to near-fault forward-directivity ground motions

An equivalent damping ratio that accounts for ground-motion spectral shape for displacement-based design of flag-shaped hysteresis systems

Strength reduction factor for inelastic-displacement estimation and design of self-centering viscous-hysteretic systems

PROPOSITION OF A SPECTRAL AMPLIFICATION MODEL FOR NEAR FAULT DIRECTIVITY EFFECT WITH UTILIZING PROBABILISTIC EARTHQUAKE SCENARIOS

The normalized inelastic displacement spectra for seismic response estimation of a SDOF system with a generalized flag-shaped hysteretic model

Estimation of effective damping ratio for cast-in-place tunnel-form system and evaluation of its role in performance point prediction

Seismic Performance Assessment of Ordinary Moment Resisting Frame Equipped with Viscous Dampers under Pulse-Like Earthquakes

Quantification of seismic demands of damage-control tension-only concentrically braced steel beam-through frames (TCBSBFs) subjected to near-fault ground motions based on the energy factor

Experimental study of earthquake input energy of low‐frequency structures equipped with a passive rate‐independent damping device

Scaling of Earthquake Models with Inhomogeneous Stress Dissipation