Comparing the Effects of Two Culture Methods to Determine the Total Heterotrophic Bacterial Colony Count in Hospital Purified Water

Xiongjing Cao,Huangguo Xiong,Yunzhou Fan,Lijuan Xiong

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s44197-023-00186-1

2024-02-16

Journal of Epidemiology and Global Health

Abstract:Accurately detecting the quantity of microorganisms in hospital purified water is of significant importance for early identification of microbial contamination and reducing the occurrence of water-borne hospital infections. The choice of detection method is a prerequisite for ensuring accurate results. Traditional Plate Count Agar (PCA) belongs to a high-nutrient medium, and there may be limitations in terms of accuracy or sensitivity in detecting microorganisms in hospital purified water. On the other hand, Reasoner's 2A agar (R2A) has characteristics, such as low-nutrient levels, low cultivation temperature, and extended incubation time, providing advantages in promoting the growth of aquatic microorganisms. This study, through comparing the differences in total colony counts between two detection methods, aims to select the method more suitable for the growth of aquatic microorganisms, offering new practical insights for accurately detecting the total count of heterotrophic bacteria in hospital purified water.

public, environmental & occupational health

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### Problems the Paper Attempts to Solve

This paper aims to compare the effectiveness of two cultivation methods in detecting the total heterotrophic bacterial colony count in hospital purified water, in order to select a more suitable method for detecting microorganisms in water. Specifically, the paper focuses on the following points:

1. **Background**:
- Accurate detection of the number of microorganisms in hospital purified water is of great significance for the early identification of microbial contamination and the reduction of waterborne hospital infections.
- Traditional Plate Count Agar (PCA) is a high-nutrient medium that may have limitations in accuracy and sensitivity when detecting microorganisms in hospital purified water.
- Reasoner’s 2A Agar (R2A) has characteristics such as low nutrient levels, low incubation temperature, and extended incubation time, which are conducive to promoting the growth of aquatic microorganisms.

2. **Research Objectives**:
- To select a more suitable method for the growth of aquatic microorganisms by comparing the differences between two cultivation methods (PCA and R2A) in detecting the total heterotrophic bacterial colony count in hospital purified water.
- To provide new practical insights for accurately detecting the total heterotrophic bacterial count in hospital purified water.

3. **Research Methods**:
- The most commonly used Plate Count Agar (PCA) method and the R2A agar cultivation method were used to detect the total number of microorganisms in water used for oral diagnosis and treatment and endoscope terminal flushing in medical institutions.
- Two water samples were inoculated using the pour plate method and membrane filtration method, respectively.
- Statistical methods (including Spearman and Pearson correlation analysis, Wilcoxon signed-rank test, paired chi-square test, and linear regression) were used to analyze the differences and associations in bacterial counts cultured by the two different methods.

4. **Research Results**:
- Among 142 water samples, the median and interquartile range of heterotrophic bacterial colony counts under the R2A cultivation method were 200 (Q1–Q3: 25–18,000), while the median and interquartile range under the PCA cultivation method were 6 (Q1–Q3: 0–3700).
- The number of heterotrophic bacterial colonies on R2A medium within 7 days was significantly higher than that on PCA medium within 2 days (P < 0.05).
- Linear regression results showed a strong linear correlation between the colony counts cultured by the R2A method and the PCA method (R² = 0.7264).
- More bacterial species were detected on R2A agar medium than on PCA agar medium.

5. **Conclusion**:
- The R2A cultivation method can better reflect the actual heterotrophic bacterial colony count in hospital purified water.
- After logarithmic transformation, there is a linear correlation between the colony counts cultured by the two methods.

### Summary

By comparing the effectiveness of PCA and R2A cultivation methods in detecting the total heterotrophic bacterial colony count in hospital purified water, this paper finds that the R2A cultivation method has higher sensitivity and accuracy in detecting aquatic microorganisms, and can more accurately reflect the microbial contamination in hospital purified water. This provides important reference and guidance for the microbial monitoring of hospital purified water.