Turbulence Modeling for Flows Around Convex Features

P. Tucker,Yan Liu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2514/6.2006-716

2006-01-09

Abstract:Reynolds Averaged Navier-Stokes model perfor mances in the stagnation and wake regions for turbulent flows with relatively large L agrangian length scales (generally approximately 50 % larger than the scale of geometrical features) approaching small cylinders (both square and circular) is explored. T he effective diameter based Reynolds number, Re W ≤ 2.5 x 10 3 . The following models are considered: a mixing-len gth; standard Spalart and Allmaras (SA) and streamline curvature (and rotation) corrected SA - SARC; Secundov’s vt-92; Secundov et al’s two equation vt-L; Wolfshtein’s k-l model; the Explicit Algebraic Stress Model (EASM) of Abid et al.; the cubic model of Craft et al.; various linear k-e models including those with wall distance based da mping functions; Menter SST and Spalding’s LVEL model. The use of differential equation distance fu nctions (implemented through Hamilton-Jacobi and Poisson equations) for palliative turbulence modeling purposes is explored. The performance of the SA model with these distance functions is also considered in the sharp convex geometry region of an airfoil trailing edge. For the cylinder, the mixing length and k-l models give strong turbulence production in the wake region. However, in accord with eddy viscosity estimates, the LVEL and Secundov νt-92 models show relatively little cylinder influenc e on turbulence. On the other hand, two equation models, like the one equation SA, suggest the cylinder gives a strong turbulence deficit in the wake region. Also, for SA, an order or magnitude cylinder diameter decrease from Re W = 2,500 to 250 surprisingly strengthens the cylind er’s disruptive influence. Importantly, results for Re W << 250 are virtually identical to those for Re W = 250 i.e. no matter how small the cylinder its influence does no t vanish. Similar tests for the LaunderSharma k-e, Menter SST and k-ω show, in accordance with physical reality, the cyl inder’s influence diminishing with size. Results suggest th e Poisson and Hamilton-Jacobi equation distance functions palliate the SA model’s erroneou s trait and improve its predictive performance in wake regions. For the airfoil, the l arger Poisson distance function increases the wake region eddy viscosity by just under 5%. . Along the stagnation line, the two equation Secundov model gives better eddy viscosity distributions than the single equation version. Als o, clearly the Poisson distance function improves the SA, mixing length, k-l and LVEL results.

Mathematics