Affray and Legislative Intent: Cautionary Tales

Alan Reed
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/002201830306700407
2003-08-01
The Journal of Criminal Law
Abstract:In comparison with other doctrinal areas of criminal law relatively little has been written on public order infractions, specifically the offence of affray. A revival of interest in this topic has been prompted by the House of Lords' decision in I v DPP and the Court of Appeal decision in Plavecz. This article examines the outcome in these cases and, more widely, seeks to deconstruct the substantive elements of the affray offence. It is suggested that it does not merit the pre-eminence currently accorded by prosecuting authorities, and that more encomia solutions to breaches of public order may be found through consideration of a gamut of alternative charges.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?