Relational Political Culture: A Critique of Inglehart's Post-Materialist Thesis

Lorien Jasny
Abstract:In "The silent revolution in Europe: Intergenerational change in postindustrial societies," Ronald Inglehart introduced his Post-Materialist hypothesis. He argued that national political cultures are in transition from a set of "Materialist" values focused on tradition and survival to "Post-Materialist" values of self-expression and quality-of-life improvements. Forty years later, this theory still dominates discussion in the field of political culture. Using a network perspective and methods from cultural anthropology, I show that Inglehart's two factor model contains an unverified assumption about the relationships between values. By testing this, I show that Inglehart's assumed structure is both empirically inaccurate and a worse approximation than many other alternatives. Unlike other critiques of Inglehart's hypothesis, this relational method provides a platform for investigating the empirical networks formed by the co-association of beliefs and the cross-national differences between these networks.
Sociology,Political Science
What problem does this paper attempt to address?