Abstract:There has been great interest in the relationship between immigration and the welfare state in recent years, and particularly since Alesina and Glaeser’s (2004) influential work. Following literatures on solidarity and fractionalization, race in the U.S. welfare state, and anti-immigrant sentiments, many contend that immigration undermines public support for social policy. This study analyzes three measures of immigration and six welfare attitudes using 1996 and 2006 International Social Survey Program (ISSP) data for 17 affluent democracies. Based on multi-level and two-way fixed-effects models, our results mostly fail to support the generic hypothesis that immigration undermines public support for social policy. The percent foreign born, net migration, and the 10-year change in the percent foreign born all fail to have robust significant negative effects on welfare attitudes. There is evidence that the percent foreign born significantly undermines the welfare attitude that government “should provide a job for everyone who wants one.” However, there is more robust evidence that net migration and change in percent foreign born have positive effects on welfare attitudes. We conclude that the compensation and chauvinism hypotheses provide greater potential for future research, and we critically consider other ways immigration could undermine the welfare state. Ultimately, this study demonstrates that factors other than immigration are far more important for public support of social policy.

Changing attitudes toward immigration in Europe, 2002-2007: a dynamic group conflict theory approach

Social Trust and Anti-immigrant Attitudes in Europe: A Longitudinal Multi-Level Analysis

Attitudes toward immigration in Europe: Cross-regional differences

A comparison of attitudes towards immigrants from the perspective of the political party vote

Blame it on my youth: the origins of attitudes towards immigration

Social Exclusion and Anti-Immigration Attitudes in Europe: The mediating role of Interpersonal Trust

Anti-immigration attitudes and the opposition to European integration: A critical assessment

Can Attitudes Toward Immigrant Explain Social Integration in Europe? EU versus Non-EU Migrant

Ethnic and cultural diversity in Europe: validating measures of ethnic and cultural background

Individual change in rejection of equal opportunities for foreigners among adolescents and young adults in Switzerland: Testing realistic conflict theory from a dynamic perspective

Immigration and Welfare Support in Germany

Inclusive versus exclusive: A cross-national comparison of the effects of subnational, national, and supranational identity

Does Immigration Undermine Public Support for Social Policy?

Algorithmic social media use and its relationship to attitude reinforcement and issue-specific political participation – The case of the 2015 European immigration movements

Mass Media and Concerns about Immigration in Germany in the 21st Century: Individual-Level Evidence over 15 Years

A Longitudinal Study of Interethnic Contacts in Germany: Estimates from a Multilevel Growth Curve Model

Perceived in-group discrimination by first and second generation immigrants from different countries of origin in 27 EU member-states

Perceptions of national identity and attitudes toward immigrants and immigration in Canada and Germany

The contact hypothesis during the European refugee crisis: Relating quality and quantity of (in)direct intergroup contact to attitudes towards refugees

Labour market dualism and immigration policy preferences

Expanding Policy Options for Immigrant Integration