Dark days for the Royal College of Physicians of London

Trish Greenhalgh

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.q771

2024-03-28

BMJ

Abstract:Trish Greenhalgh says an urgent inquiry is needed to investigate how the Royal College of Physicians of London has handled the debate on physician associates

medicine, general & internal

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

Helen Salisbury: Ensuring the safety of physician associates' practice

Helen Salisbury

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.q676

2024-03-20

BMJ

Abstract:Since 2015 the Royal College of Physicians (RCP) has hosted the Faculty of Physician Associates. On 13 March the RCP held an extraordinary general meeting at the request of fellows of the college. The main reason for this was concern about the role of physician associates (PAs) in the NHS, and there was general agreement on four of the five motions presented. However, the college resisted a call by some of the fellows for caution in the pace and scale of the rollout of PA roles.1 The original motion called for a pause, rather than merely caution, and this was regarded as not feasible and was watered down—but even this new version is being opposed. Fellows have until 20 March to vote, with results expected on the 25th.The meeting was a masterclass in how not to engage with your membership. The college's presentation of the results of a survey of...

medicine, general & internal
Physician associates: a pause in rollout is needed

Partha Kar

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.q634

2024-03-13

BMJ

Abstract:A seminal moment beckons in the history of the Royal College of Physicians (RCP). Tomorrow the RCP is due to hold an extraordinary general meeting (EGM)—notably only the third EGM in its 505 year history. The centre of debate? Physician associates or medical associate professions (MAPs): their role, their relevance, their scope, regulation, and everything else.12 It is a debate which perhaps should have happened many years ago, yet here we are on the eve of such an event.Before going into the motions at hand, there is a huge lesson for many to learn from how this debate has escalated and how we got to this point. In my experience, any previous attempts to raise concerns about the role, scope, and regulation of PAs have been brushed aside as the gripes of a small cohort of disgruntled groups, or just as a bit of social media noise. But this attitude...

medicine, general & internal
Why the fuss about physician associates?

Margaret McCartney

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.q862

2024-04-18

BMJ

Abstract:Features of the debate around physician associates (PAs) have crystallised a range of underlying problems in the NHS into a lightning rod. This now has serious implications for the future of general practice and the medical profession itself. Unless we look back and understand why we have medical royal colleges and regulation we risk further alienating doctors—current and future.To be clear: my argument is not with the many individual PAs who have, with good faith, engaged in their training and work, with high aspirations for patient care. The current crisis is not their fault. The same cannot be said for the medical and political leaders who have led us here. Nor can we blame every current leader: this crisis has been drip fed for years, with those expressing concerns or asking questions urged to "be kind or be quiet." But we should really be looking further back to understand what...

medicine, general & internal
Physician associates: Parliament was "misadvised" on RCP's support for regulation, fellows say

Jacqui Wise

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.q2047

2024-09-19

BMJ

Abstract:The UK parliament was "misadvised" when the Royal College of Physicians of London (RCP) was cited as approving new legislation giving the General Medical Council powers to regulate physician associates, claims a group of college fellows.Their open letter, published in The BMJ,1 follows a dispute between the membership and the RCP council over governance and the college's previous stance on physician associates (PAs), which was supportive.23The letter, signed by 32 RCP fellows, has been sent to Layla Moran, chair of the Health and Social Care Committee; the health and social care secretary, Wes Streeting; and several members of the House of Lords.Since 2015 the RCP has hosted the Faculty of Physician Associates, the professional membership body for the UK's PAs, but the faculty is due to close at the end of this year—around the time the General Medical Council (GMC) will begin regulating associates, in line with the Anaesthesia Associates...

medicine, general & internal
"A whirlwind of anecdotes"? The Academy of Medical Royal Colleges seems unconvinced by evidence of concerns about physician associates

Martin McKee,Charlotte Bolton

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.q2154

2024-10-02

BMJ

Abstract:The Academy of Medical Royal Colleges, the umbrella organisation for the colleges, has intervened in the debate about the role and status of physician and anaesthesia associates (PAs). It has now written to the secretary of state for health and social care and the chief executive of NHS England to request a rapid review of PA's role.1 PAs, initially created as assistants to doctors, have been taking on an increasing number of complex roles, from seeing undifferentiated patients in primary care to child protection.2 This has led to growing concerns for patient safety, the cost and capacity for doctors to supervise them, and the impact on medical training.In a letter published on 30 September, the academy asks a series of questions, including whether there is evidence that PAs are unsafe.1 Yet, if it was commenting on the introduction of a new medicine or technology, it would surely reverse the burden...

medicine, general & internal
Partha Kar: We need honest, sensible conversation about physician associates—not false promises

Partha Kar

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.q2060

2024-09-21

BMJ

Abstract:The plan to introduce and further expand physician associates through the NHS workforce plan has become a clinical, financial, and strategic mess. The royal colleges—including the Royal College of Physicians, the Royal College of Anaesthetists, and the Royal College of General Practitioners—are finally starting to develop national scope for the role.1Problems will arise with having multiple scopes of practice from different royal colleges setting different baselines or ceilings. This would create further conflict and raises questions about what happens if trusts decide to ignore their guidance—and whether doing so would put them at risk of legal challenge. This has opened a can of worms because there was a lack of defined scope for many staff for years, allowing local scope to develop without quality control. My advice to the colleges is to recognise that trust between their members and leaders is frayed, and pushing through scope for physician associates without...

medicine, general & internal
Doctors need protected time to conduct clinical research, says RCP

Gareth Iacobucci

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.q2362

2024-10-25

BMJ

Abstract:The Royal College of Physicians of London (RCP) has called for doctors to be given more ringfenced time to conduct clinical research.The call came as the 2023 census of UK consultant physicians conducted by the RCP, the Royal College of Physicians of Edinburgh, and the Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons of Glasgow found that only 41% of respondents (1234 of 2992) were involved in research, with a lack of ringfenced time in job plans being cited as the main thing stopping them.Tom Solomon, academic vice president at the RCP said, "Clinical research is a cornerstone of medical advancement, and it is vital that NHS doctors are given the time and resources they need to pursue research alongside their clinical duties. The benefits are clear: not only does research lead to lifesaving innovations in patient care, it also enhances training for resident doctors and job satisfaction for NHS consultants."Of 1022...

medicine, general & internal
Physician associates and RCGP policy — some plain speaking

James Thallon

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3399/bjgp24x739989

2024-11-29

British Journal of General Practice

Abstract:I recently spoke to a physician associate (PA) who was desperately distressed about fatigue and the threat to their career in general practice and livelihood. The PA had been happy in their work but now felt the cold chill of disapproval beginning to seep down the corridors of their provincial employer. This PA, in common with most colleagues, is under 30, in the vulnerable early ...

medicine, general & internal,primary health care
RCP president is asked to resign over handling of physician associates row

Elisabeth Mahase

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.q1291

2024-06-12

BMJ

Abstract:Senior officers at the Royal College of Physicians (RCP) have called on President Sarah Clarke to resign, after over 80 members expressed a lack of confidence in the college's leadership because of inaction on physician associates (PAs).1The letter, signed by five of the six senior RCP officers, recognised Clarke's "hard work to try and deal with the challenging matters that have faced the college," but said that they are "increasingly concerned that she has lost the confidence" of the membership.The officers said they met with Clarke on 9 June and "asked her to resign the role and give our college a fresh start." They added, "This is a critical time for our profession and we need someone at the helm with the skills to advocate fiercely for physicians."Signatories included treasurer Simon Bowman, vice president education and training Mumtaz Patel, vice president Wales Hilary Williams, academic vice president Ramesh Arasaradnam, and...

medicine, general & internal
Almost a Quarter of Royal College Fellows Say Their Hospitals Cannot Deliver Continuity of Care

Nigel Hawkes

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.e4942

2012-01-01

BMJ

Abstract:Radical changes are needed in the way hospitals are organised and run, the Royal College of Physicians’ Future Hospital Commission is likely to recommend when it reports next year. At a meeting at the college on 17 July to report progress, Tim Evans, academic vice president, said that work so far had identified that hospitals were under substantial stress, often providing a disjointed service to patients with a lack of compassion and continuity of care. A survey of the college’s fellows had shown many concerns, ranging from worries about their hospital’s ability to deliver …
There is a role for physician associates in the NHS

Sarah Clarke

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.q618

2024-03-13

BMJ

Abstract:We are in the midst of a political and professional storm over the role of the Royal College of Physicians (RCP) in supporting physician associates (PAs).1 Concerns around the profession's scope of practice, supervision, and regulation have come to the fore in recent months. The NHS has changed beyond recognition since I qualified as a doctor almost 40 years ago and I genuinely believe that the development of multidisciplinary team (MDT) working has improved access to services, evidence-based care, and continuity of care. On 13 March 2024, the RCP will hold an extraordinary general meeting (EGM) to discuss these concerns and, whatever its outcome, we must use it as an important opportunity to further the conversation about how these multidisciplinary teams—including PAs—can work together safely to provide the best care possible for patients.PAs have worked in the NHS for over 20 years, and since 2015 the RCP has supported the...

medicine, general & internal
RCP president steps down "with immediate effect" after physician associates row

Matthew Limb

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.q1383

2024-06-22

BMJ

Abstract:Sarah Clarke, president of the Royal College of Physicians (RCP), is stepping aside "with immediate effect" as the college enters fresh turmoil in the ongoing controversy over physician associates (PAs).Clarke, who had been asked by members to step down amid widespread criticism over her leadership,1 will be "available until September to support interim presidential arrangements," the college said. The RCP council will meet on 3 July to discuss a longer term solution.The RCP said in a statement on 20 June that it recognised the need for a reset. "This is an unprecedented situation for the college, and our priority during this period of transition is to ensure stability and continue to deliver the priorities of our members," it said.The college has already commissioned the King's Fund to carry out an independent review to learn lessons from its extraordinary general meeting in March,2 which blew wide open the rift between the...

medicine, general & internal
Helen Salisbury: Risk and responsibility when working with physician associates

Helen Salisbury

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.q1270

2024-06-12

BMJ

Abstract:One of the issues troubling doctors in general, and GPs in particular, is the question of whether they're responsible—and indeed medicolegally liable—if a physician associate (PA) under their supervision makes a mistake. Other members of our multidisciplinary teams have their own professional registration, but PAs currently do not. There's been much discussion of one case where a doctor in an emergency department was sanctioned by the Medical Practitioners Tribunal Service for failing to go back to take a collateral history and perform his own examination of a patient already seen by a PA.1Last week the General Medical Council's chief executive, Charlie Massey, wrote to NHS leaders to offer reassurance that "doctors are not accountable for the decisions and actions of PAs and AAs [anaesthesia associates] who they supervise."2 Although this will come as a relief, there was a rider: "doctors will not be held accountable provided they have delegated responsibility...

medicine, general & internal
"PA mess" is a combination of self-interest and protectionism

Angus H N Whitfield

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.q2328

2024-11-01

BMJ

Abstract:The Royal College of General Practitioners (RCGP) made reference to its members survey when changing its position on the role of physician associates (PAs) in general practice, 123 which is regrettable, as it represents poor evidence informed decision making. The response rate of the survey was approximately 10% of the college's membership, and 40% of all respondents had never worked with PAs. A third of respondents were GP trainees, who would never have had the experience of taking clinical responsibility for another healthcare professional.My practice has been training PA students since 2017. In my 16 years as a full time GP partner (nine clinical sessions a week), I have seen major errors that affected patient health or wellbeing made by GP partners, salaried GPs, locum GPs, GP registrars, advanced nurse practitioners, practice nurses, healthcare assistants, clinical pharmacists, social prescribers, and PAs. We have never employed a paramedic, but it would...

medicine, general & internal
Physician associate deployment in primary care: running before walking

Thomas Oswald

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3399/bjgp24x738369

2024-06-01

British Journal of General Practice

Abstract:A few weeks have passed since the extraordinary general meeting at the Royal College of Physicians (RCP) debating physician associate (PA) roll-out and scope of practice. During the opening presentation, data were shown stating that the majority of PAs are currently employed in primary care settings in England. David Nicholl, one of the RCP fellows responsible for tabling the motions at the meeting, opened his remarks with 'We are not primary care physicians' when addressing the college audience. He further alluded to concerns about PAs seeing undifferentiated patients as the first point of contact in primary care. Following the meeting, a number of other controversies were brought to light. The scandal concerning data misrepresentation in relation to surveyed members' attitudes to PAs led to the resignation of the RCP registrar. Another controversy related to a question from a fellow about the role of PAs in the multidisciplinary team seemingly ignored by RCP Council members. A third discussed financial and legal implications for the RCP laid out by the treasurer ...

medicine, general & internal,primary health care
Partha Kar: Leng's review of physician and anaesthesia associates is welcome—with guarded optimism

Partha Kar

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.q2608

2024-11-28

BMJ

Abstract:Finally, we're here. After months of heated debates, social media uproar, royal colleges in turmoil, and the reputation of many national organisations being questioned, the worm has turned. The health and social care secretary, Wes Streeting, has called for a review of how physician and anaesthesia associates are deployed in the NHS.1The chair of the review, Gillian Leng, has a strong reputation and is well placed to conduct it. Since the stipulation is to look at data and views neutrally and to reach a decision about whether these roles are a cost effective use of taxpayers' money, the former chief of the National Institute for Health and Care Excellence is as good as it gets.So, what next? One thing is to allow open communication from all parties and ensure that there's a genuine desire to investigate this thoroughly. This issue won't just go away. As I've previously mentioned, doctors have...

medicine, general & internal
Doctors are under attack from all sides, BMA chair tells annual meeting

Gareth Iacobucci

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.q1402

2024-06-25

BMJ

Abstract:The medical profession is under attack financially, professionally, and morally, and must continue to fight to preserve itself, the BMA's chair of council has said.In a speech to the association's annual representative meeting in Belfast, Philip Banfield took aim at the government over industrial action, funding cuts, and the state of general practice. He also highlighted doctors' fears of speaking out about patient safety and announced a judicial review claim against the General Medical Council over the way it plans to regulate physician and anaesthesia associates, which the BMA says will lead to a dangerous blurring of lines for patients.Discussing the fractured relations between doctors and ministers, Banfield expressed his frustration that while consultants and specialist, associate specialist, and specialty (SAS) doctors in England have been able to secure pay deals, the dispute with junior doctors has now lasted 20 months without resolution. He said that calling an election does...

medicine, general & internal
The debate rages on: physician-assisted suicide in an ethical light

John Shenouda,Michael Blaber,Robert George,James Haslam

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.bja.2024.01.002

IF: 11.719

2024-01-01

British Journal of Anaesthesia

Abstract:The British Medical Association and some Royal Colleges have recently changed their stance on physician-assisted suicide from 'opposed' to forms of 'neutral'. The Royal College of Anaesthetists will poll members soon on whether to follow suit. Elsewhere neutrality amongst professional bodies has preceded legalisation of physician-assisted suicide. We examine the arguments relevant to the anaesthesia community and its potential impact in the UK.

anesthesiology
Helen Salisbury: Physician associates have no role in general practice

Helen Salisbury

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.q2083

2024-09-25

BMJ

Abstract:In a survey reported in June, the Royal College of General Practitioners (RCGP) asked for its members' views on physician associates (PAs) in general practice.1 In the light of the responses the college drew up some principles for how PAs should be working—covering induction, supervision, and their scope of practice. These guidelines haven't yet been made public, but one paragraph was circulated: it advised that where PAs were already in post, their scope and role could be set locally by their supervising GP.2This proposed exemption from the guidelines caused some dismay on social media. Members had indicated in the survey that they didn't think the way PAs currently worked was safe, so many people pointed out that it made no sense to say we must do better with future PAs while carrying on as we are with those already working.At an RCGP council meeting on Friday 20 September, that paragraph...

medicine, general & internal
David Oliver: Social media's false polarisation is no good for balanced NHS discussion

David Oliver

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.q147

2024-01-25

BMJ

Abstract:With the ongoing doctors' strikes in England, nursing unions re-escalating their own campaign on pay, worsening morale and retention in health and social care, and growing disquiet among doctors about other clinical disciplines encroaching on their roles or training, healthcare groups on social media have become fractious. But are public platforms such as X (formerly Twitter), Facebook, or Reddit the best places for constructive, nuanced debate?Later this month the General Medical Council (GMC) will update its guidance for doctors who use social media. These platforms have given practitioners immediate access to personal views and direct contact with even the most senior leaders and commentators. Earlier in my career you could phone a radio station, sign a petition, go on a protest march, write to your MP or trade union or a royal college or newspaper—but there was nothing so immediate, so public. When I was a junior doctor, for instance,...

medicine, general & internal

Dark days for the Royal College of Physicians of London

Helen Salisbury: Ensuring the safety of physician associates' practice

Physician associates: a pause in rollout is needed

Why the fuss about physician associates?

Physician associates: Parliament was "misadvised" on RCP's support for regulation, fellows say

"A whirlwind of anecdotes"? The Academy of Medical Royal Colleges seems unconvinced by evidence of concerns about physician associates

Partha Kar: We need honest, sensible conversation about physician associates—not false promises

Doctors need protected time to conduct clinical research, says RCP

Physician associates and RCGP policy — some plain speaking

RCP president is asked to resign over handling of physician associates row

Almost a Quarter of Royal College Fellows Say Their Hospitals Cannot Deliver Continuity of Care

There is a role for physician associates in the NHS

RCP president steps down "with immediate effect" after physician associates row

Helen Salisbury: Risk and responsibility when working with physician associates

"PA mess" is a combination of self-interest and protectionism

Physician associate deployment in primary care: running before walking

Partha Kar: Leng's review of physician and anaesthesia associates is welcome—with guarded optimism

Doctors are under attack from all sides, BMA chair tells annual meeting

The debate rages on: physician-assisted suicide in an ethical light

Helen Salisbury: Physician associates have no role in general practice

David Oliver: Social media's false polarisation is no good for balanced NHS discussion