Abstract:Objectives: To contribute towards an understanding of hospital board composition and to explore board oversight of patient safety and health care quality in the English NHS. Methods: We reviewed the theory related to hospital board governance and undertook two national surveys about board management in NHS acute and specialist hospital trusts in England. The first survey was issued to 150 trusts in 2011/2012 and was completed online via a dedicated web tool. A total 145 replies were received (97% response rate). The second online survey was undertaken in 2012/2013 and targeted individual board members, using a previously validated standard instrument on board members' attitudes and competencies (the Board Self-Assessment Questionnaire). A total of 334 responses were received from 165 executive and 169 non-executive board members, providing at least one response from 95 of the 144 NHS trusts then in existence (66% response rate). Results: Over 90% of the English NHS trust boards had 10-15 members. We found no significant difference in board size between trusts of different types (e.g. Foundation Trusts versus non-Foundation Trusts and Teaching Hospital Trusts versus non-Teaching Hospital Trusts). Clinical representation on boards was limited: around 62% had three or fewer members with clinical backgrounds. For about two-thirds of the trusts (63%), board members with a clinical background comprised less than 30% of the members. Boards were using a wide range and mix of quantitative performance metrics and soft intelligence (e.g. walk-arounds, patient stories) to monitor their organisations with regard to patient safety. The Board Self-Assessment Questionnaire data showed generally high or very high levels of agreement with desirable statements of practice in each of its six dimensions. Aggregate levels of agreement within each dimension ranged from 73% (for the dimension addressing interpersonal issues) to 85% (on the political). Conclusions: English NHS boards largely hold a wide range of attitudes and behaviours that might be expected to benefit patient safety and quality. However, there is significant scope for improvement as regards formal training for board members on quality and safety, routine morbidity reporting at boards and attention to the interpersonal dynamics within boards. Directors with clinical backgrounds remain a minority on most boards despite policies to increase their representation. A better understanding of board composition, actions and attitudes should help refine policy recommendations around boards.

Almost a Quarter of Royal College Fellows Say Their Hospitals Cannot Deliver Continuity of Care

Hospitals Need Encouragement to Become Part of Integrated Care, Report Says

Lack of Community Care is Responsible for Crisis in Hospitals, Meeting Hears

Future Hospital Commission, 10 years on - Lessons learned and next steps: The Chief Registrar Programme - what has been achieved?

CQC survey: Patient satisfaction in England's hospital care fails to improve, but trust in doctors remains high

Nhs Chief Tells Politicians to Embrace Hospital Closures to Improve Services for Patients

Reaffirming our commitment to the NHS is needed now more than ever

Dark days for the Royal College of Physicians of London

Alternatives to Hospital for Older People Must Be Found, Says Nhs Chief

Only 12 of 211 Commissioning Groups Are Acting on Integrated Care, Conference Hears

Patients' Actual Care Pathways Often Differ Markedly from Doctors' Perceptions

Continuity of care in general practice: avoid the blunt sledgehammers of national policy

New Models of Healthcare Will Replace Nearly Three Quarters of NHS by 2024, Report Says.

The BMJ Commission on the Future of Academic Medicine

Is continuity of primary care declining in England? Practice-level longitudinal study from 2012 to 2017

Overseeing oversight: governance of quality and safety by hospital boards in the English NHS

'It's like juggling fire daily': Well-being, workload and burnout in the British NHS - A survey of 721 physicians

Partha Kar: We need honest, sensible conversation about physician associates—not false promises

Expert Questions Whether NHS Can Be Transformed Without Further Upheaval.

Declaring a health and care emergency

The performance of general practice in the English National Health Service (NHS): an analysis using Starfield's framework for primary care