Abstract:Frequent violations of fair principles in real-life settings raise the fundamental question of whether such principles can guarantee the existence of a self-enforcing equilibrium in a free economy. We show that elementary principles of distributive justice guarantee that a pure-strategy Nash equilibrium exists in a finite economy where agents freely (and non-cooperatively) choose their inputs and derive utility from their pay. Chief among these principles is that: 1) your pay should not depend on your name, and 2) a more productive agent should not earn less. When these principles are violated, an equilibrium may not exist. Moreover, we uncover an intuitive condition -- technological monotonicity -- that guarantees equilibrium uniqueness and efficiency. We generalize our findings to economies with social justice and inclusion, implemented in the form of progressive taxation and redistribution, and guaranteeing a basic income to unproductive agents. Our analysis uncovers a new class of strategic form games by incorporating normative principles into non-cooperative game theory. Our results rely on no particular assumptions, and our setup is entirely non-parametric. Illustrations of the theory include applications to exchange economies, surplus distribution in a firm, contagion and self-enforcing lockdown in a networked economy, and bias in the academic peer-review system. Keywords: Market justice; Social justice; Inclusion; Ethics; Discrimination; Self-enforcing contracts; Fairness in non-cooperative games; Pure strategy Nash equilibrium; Efficiency. JEL Codes: C72, D30, D63, J71, J38

Property rights out of anarchy? The Demsetz hypothesis in a game of conflict

The Social Construction Logic of Property Rights:A review on the property rights studies of Chinese sociologists from the perspective of game theory

Endowment Effects in Evolutionary Game Theory: Enhancing Property Rights

Trust with Private and Common Property: Effects of Stronger Property Right Entitlements

Endogenous property rights regimes, common-pool resources and trade

A model of the origins of basic property rights

An Evolutionary Analysis of the Assignment of Property Rights

Strangers’ property

Competition among the Elites, Property Rights Protection and Economic Performance

Trust in Private and Common Property Experiments

Price of Anarchy in a Double-Sided Critical Distribution System

A Free and Fair Economy: A Game of Justice and Inclusion

Why do elites extend property rights: unlocking investment and the switch to public goods

Property between Natural and Acquired Right

A sequential game of endowment effect and natural property rights

A Model of Enclosures: Coordination, Conflict, and Efficiency in the Transformation of Land Property Rights

Territory in the state of nature

The Tragedy of ‘The Tragedy of the Commons’ – Hardin vs. the Property Rights Theorists

Ours, not yours: Property rights, poaching and deterrence in common-pool resources

Investment in the Common Good: Free Rider Effect and the Stability of Mixed Strategy Equilibria