Trade liberalization and child labor

Liqiu Zhao,Fei Wang,Zhong Zhao
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.chieco.2020.101575
IF: 4.744
2021-02-01
China Economic Review
Abstract:<p>This paper exploits a quasi-natural experiment – the U.S. granting of Permanent Normal Trade Relations (PNTR) to China after China's accession to the World Trade Organization – to examine whether trade liberalization affects the incidence of child labor. PNTR permanently set U.S. duties on Chinese imports at low Normal Trade Relations (NTR) levels and removed the uncertainty associated with annual renewals of China's NTR status. We find that the PNTR was significantly associated with the rising incidence of child labor in China. A one percentage point reduction in expected export tariffs raises the odds of child labor by a 1.2 percentage point. The effects are greater for girls, older children, rural children, and children with less-educated parents. The effect of trade liberalization on the incidence of child labor, however, tends to weaken in the long run, probably because trade liberalization can induce exporters to upgrade technology and thus have less demand for unskilled workers.</p>
economics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
This paper attempts to explore the impact of trade liberalization on the phenomenon of child labor in China. Specifically, the author utilizes the quasi-natural experiment of the United States granting China Permanent Normal Trade Relations (PNTR) after China's accession to the World Trade Organization (WTO) in 2001 to analyze the effect of reduced trade policy uncertainty on the incidence of child labor. The study finds that trade liberalization significantly increased the incidence of child labor in China, especially for girls, older children, rural children, and children with less educated parents. However, this effect diminishes in the long term, possibly because trade liberalization prompts exporters to upgrade their technology, thereby reducing the demand for unskilled labor. The main contributions of the paper are: 1. **Filling the research gap**: Although child labor is a prevalent issue globally, especially in developing countries, there is relatively little research focused on China. This paper is one of the few studies that explore the issue of child labor in China. 2. **New perspective**: This is one of the earliest studies to link trade liberalization with the reduction of external trade policy uncertainty and examine its impact on the incidence of child labor in China. 3. **Methodological innovation**: By utilizing the quasi-natural experiment brought about by changes in U.S. trade policy and employing a Difference-in-Differences (DID) strategy, the study effectively identifies the causal effect of trade liberalization on child labor. 4. **Empirical results**: The study finds that trade liberalization increases the incidence of child labor in the short term, which contrasts with the income effect found in most studies (i.e., trade policy increases household income, thereby reducing child labor). In China, low-skill-intensive industries rapidly expanded due to trade liberalization, increasing the demand for unskilled child labor, while the increase in household income did not immediately materialize. In summary, through rigorous methods and detailed data, this paper reveals the complex impact of trade liberalization on the phenomenon of child labor, providing important references for relevant policy-making.