When Trade Discourages Political Favoritism: Evidence from China

Yi Lu,Tuan‐Hwee Sng,Yingke Zhou
2014-01-01
Abstract:In developing countries, governments often distort resource allocation by protecting politically favored firms. If trade liberalization increases the cost of protection, it may discourage political favoritism and therefore improve allocative efficiency. By studying China’s WTO accession, this paper empirically investigate if trade liberalization leads to the reallocation of market shares from politically favored but less productive firms to more productive ones. We find that trade liberalization induces a 2.5 percentage points decline in the output share of state-owned enterprises and reduces the standard deviation of Chinese manufacturing firm productivity by 1.4% between 2001 and 2005. The decline in SOE output share is driven by an increase in import competition and takes place at the extensive margin and through intra-industry reallocation of production. Interestingly, the likelihood of SOE exit is linked to political affiliation instead of performance: the SOEs affiliated to county and township governments were the worst hit while those affiliated to upper layers (central, provincial, and city) of the government were largely unaffected. Our results suggest that apart from the familiar sources of gains from trade, trade could also deliver welfare gains by reducing inefficiencies arising from the political economy.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?