Abstract:In this article we extend our work on the limitations of the Gardner and Winner U-curved artistic development hypothesis [Gardner, Howard, Winner, Ellen, 1982. First intimations of artistry. In: Strauss, S. (Ed.), U-shaped Development. Academic Press, New York, pp. 147–168]. In our previous work we have cast serious doubt on the supposed universal validity of that thesis by showing that non-Western judges do not necessarily assess the aesthetic merits of a given set of drawings in the same way as do the Western judges used in the research allegedly supporting the U-curve hypothesis. While we were able almost perfectly to replicate the characteristic U-curve using Western judges—with drawings made by very young children ranked almost as highly as those of mature artists—Chinese-educated judges assessing the same sample of drawings produced an upward-sloping curve in which the drawings of the youngest children ranked lowest. In this article we begin to explore the reasons behind this apparent inter-cultural difference in aesthetic judgement. On the basis of hints from a recent pilot study as well as from what is known about characteristic differences between Western and Chinese cultural standards, we hypothesize that the difference between the Western and Chinese judges’ evaluations in our earlier study might be due to differences in their appreciation of the degree of graphic skill displayed in the drawings they were asked to assess. Whereas Westerners with an art-education background are likely to be steeped in a Modernist aesthetic which values unspoilt originality above all else and which tends to downgrade technical skill, Chinese culture reputedly values skill and technique as necessary pre-conditions for artistic expression. In order to test this hypothesis we had independent judges score each drawing in the sample according to the relative amount of graphic skill it displayed. We then correlated the skill scores with the aesthetic evaluations of our initial Western and Chinese-educated judges. The results provide moderate support for our hypothesis. The Chinese-educated judges’ assessments are consistently more strongly correlated with level of graphic skill than those of the Western judges. While the Western judges did appear to appreciate skill as a part of the aesthetic value of a drawing, they did so only for the drawings produced by adolescent and adult artists. Their assessment of the work of non-artists did not appear to have anything to do with the skill level shown. The Chinese-educated judges, by contrast, seemed to hold skill in higher esteem than the Western judges and did so across all age/skill groups.

Abstract art grandmasters score like class D amateurs

Monkeys get a silver in Abstract Art Olympics

A scientific inquiry into modern art

The Influence of Art Expertise and Training on Emotion and Preference Ratings for Representational and Abstract Artworks

Quantifying Artistic Success: Ranking French Painters—and Paintings—from Impressionism to Cubism

The impact of level of expertise on the evaluation of original and altered versions of post-impressionistic paintings

Concrete and abstract thinking styles and art preferences in a sample of serious art collectors

Everyone Can Be Picasso? A Computational Framework into the Myth of Human versus AI Painting

Statistical Image Properties in Large Subsets of Traditional Art, Bad Art, and Abstract Art

Algorithms can Mimic Human Piano Performance: The Deep Blues of Music

Art in the eye of the beholder: the perception of art during monocular viewing

A Comparison Study of Human and Machine-Generated Creativity

The effect of art expertise on visual symmetry and asymmetry preference

Boring mathematics, artistes pompiers and impressionists

Beauty and Paintings: Aesthetic Experience in Patients with Behavioral Variant Frontotemporal Dementia When Viewing Abstract and Concrete Paintings

A Game of Dice: Machine Learning and the Question Concerning Art

The Languages of Art: How Representational and Abstract Painters Conceptualize Their Work in Terms of Language

Teaching art versus teaching taste: what art teachers can learn from looking at a cross-cultural evaluation of children's art

Discerning Digital from Canvas: Investigating Visual Distinction between AI-Generated Art and Actual Art among Far Eastern University’s Institute of Architecture and Fine Arts (IARFA) and Non-IARFA Students

The neural determinants of abstract beauty