Quantifying Artistic Success: Ranking French Painters—and Paintings—from Impressionism to Cubism

David W. Galenson

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/01615440209603140

2002-01-01

Abstract:For 35 leading painters who lived in France during the first century of modern art, this article uses textbook illustrations as the basis for measuring the importance of both painters and individual paintings. The rankings pose an interesting puzzle: Why do some of the greatest artists not produce famous paintings, and why do some relatively minor artists produce some of the most famous individual paintings? The answer may lie in an important difference in approach between experimental and conceptual painters. Experimental artists work incrementally, their innovations appear gradually, and they generally do their best work late in their careers; conceptual artists innovate more suddenly, produce individual breakthrough works, and usually do their best work early in their careers. This article demonstrates that artistic success can usefully be quantified, and that doing so increases our understanding of the working methods of modern painters.