Editorial – TREE special issue

Chandan Jain Marie Gaarder Sudhanshu Handa a International Initiative for Impact Evaluation (3ie)b American Institutes for Research and University of North CarolinaChandan Jain manages and supports 3ie's livelihoods programs. He has significant research experience in social policy,gender,and adolescent development and his work at 3ie focuses on providing technical and management lead to the ongoing impact evaluation under the 3ie's livelihoods programs. He also manages 3ie's initiative on Transparency,Reproducibility,and Ethical Evidence (TREE). Chandan holds a PhD in Economics from Shiv Nadar University and a Master's in Economics from TERI University,India.Marie Gaarder is the executive director of 3ie,leading the organisation's efforts to improve lives in low- and middle-income countries by supporting the generation and effective use of high-quality and relevant evidence to inform decision-making. Marie has over 25 years of experience managing operational and research projects with a development focus. She has also worked as the director of the evaluation department at the Norwegian Agency for Development Cooperation,where she was in charge of independent evaluation of programmes and activities financed over the Norwegian aid budget. Marie is the co-chair of the International Development Coordinating Group within the Campbell Collaboration,a member of the Research Ethics Review Committee of the Partnership for Economic Policy,a member of the DFID-CDC Evaluation & Learning Programme Steering Group,and a member of the WFP's impact evaluation Strategic Advisory Panel (SAP). Marie holds a PhD in Economics from University College London,an MSc in Economics from London School of Economics and a graduate degree in Political Science,Arabic and Economics from the University of Oslo,Norway.Sudhanshu Handa is a 3ie senior research fellow and Kenan Eminent Professor of Public Policy at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill. A trained economist,Ashu is one of the principal investigators of The Transfer Project,an initiative in partnership with UNICEF and FAO to document the wide-ranging impacts of government sponsored cash transfer programs in Sub-Saharan Africa. Through the Transfer Project and its collaborators,he has lead seven large-scale evaluations of national cash transfer programs in Sub-Saharan Africa. His current work involves long-term follow-ups of these evaluations to understand the intergenerational effects of cash transfers on the adult children of the original recipients. Handa previously worked at UNICEF's Office of Research,the Inter-American Development Bank,the University of the West Indies-Mona,and the International Food Policy Research Institute. He holds a PhD in Economics from the University of Toronto.

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/19439342.2024.2390816

2024-09-10

Journal of Development Effectiveness

Abstract:Over the last two decades, there has been a significant increase in the number of evaluations aimed at generating evidence on what works to improve development outcomes. Using data from 3ie's Development Evidence Portal, we find that there were just over 1,500 IEs published in the 20 years from 1990 to 2009, and over 18,000 published so far in the 15 years from 2010 to 2024. Additionally, there is a growing interest in integrating evidence into the policy-making process to enhance the lives of individuals. Public policies and development programmes affect millions of people, making credible and ethical evidence crucial for implementing the right policies for poverty alleviation. Concerns, however, exist around the credibility, rigour, and reproducibility of existing evidence. Recent literature, see for instance, Christensen and Miguel ( Citation 2018 ), Andrews and Kasy ( Citation 2019 ), Miguel ( Citation 2021 ) have pointed out various issues, such as selective reporting, p-hacking, lack of reproducibility, and ethical concerns plaguing social sciences research. In this regard, 3ie's initiative on Transparency, Reproducibility, and Ethical Evidence (TREE) has promoted the uptake of best practices and capacity development amongst researchers, especially in low-and-middle-income countries, to ensure that the generated evidence is credible and produced using ethical practices. This special issue is part of 3ie's mission to improve the evidence generation process and is dedicated to issues around transparency and ethics in the context of impact evaluations.

development studies