Abstract:The effect of mortgage amortization (debt repayment) on wealth accumulation is critical in understanding savings-debt repayment fungibility, macroprudential policies, and the importance of homeownership for household wealth building. Nevertheless, it is not well understood and difficult to cleanly identify. We provide the first empirical evidence on these effects using individual administrative data to examine plausibly exogenous variation in the timing of home purchases surrounding a January 2013 mortgage reform in the Netherlands which restricted the use of interest only mortgages for first time home buyers. For those who bought just after the regulation, we find little-to-no change in the accumulation of non-mortgage savings, even four years later, despite a significant increase in debt repayment. This surprisingly implies a near 1-for-1 rise in net worth - a response consistent with little savings-debt fungibility – financed via increased labor supply and reduced expenditures. Results hold using life-events, such as the birth of a child, as an instrument for the timing of home purchase, and appear unaffected by potential selection or confounded treatment concerns. Effects are unchanged focusing on buyers with substantial liquid savings and across the spectrum of ages, suggesting general applicability beyond just non-savers and the young. Our results are broadly consistent with savings decisions being almost entirely driven by short-term consumption smoothing and models of wealth accumulation driven by default settings, commitment devices, and mental accounting. Overall, our findings suggest that homeownership, when coupled with amortizing mortgages, are key drivers of wealth accumulation, and that the amortization-wealth elasticity is a crucial consideration for policy makers.

Mortgage interest deductions? Not a bad idea after all

Implications of US Tax Policy for House Prices, Rents, and Homeownership

Housing, Distribution, and Welfare

Mortgage Amortization and Wealth Accumulation

Tax Deductibility, Market Frictions, and Price Discrimination: Evidence from the Mortgage Market.

Interest Deduction Policy of American Home Mortgage and Experience Reference

The effect of homeownership on migrant household savings: Evidence from the removal of home purchase restrictions in China

Housing Price, Consumption, and Financial Market: Evidence from Urban Household Data in China

HOUSE PRICES, RENTAL COSTS, AND MORTGAGE INTEREST RATES

Subsidies or green taxes? Evaluating the distributional effects of housing renovation policies among Dutch households

Impact of weak substitution between owning and renting a dwelling on housing market

Evidence of Government Subsidy on Mortgage Rate and Default: Revisited

Redistribution Through Tax Relief

Evaluating Homeownership as the Solution to Wealth Inequality

Partial Homeownership: A Quantitative Analysis

House prices and the allocation of consumer credit

The Consumption‐Stimulating Effect of Public Rental Housing in China

Life and Liberty in the Pursuit of Housing: Rethinking Renting and Owning in Post-Crisis America

Mortgage Design, Repayment Schedules, and Household Borrowing

Mortgage Refinancing, Consumer Spending, and Competition: Evidence from the Home Affordable Refinance Program

Tackling barriers to (beneficial) housing mobility