Abstract:Despite persistent housing affordability issues, energy policy and housing renovation are usually investigated separately from housing costs other than energy. Researchers have examined the financial viability of renovation attending to building conditions and the socio-economic characteristics of their occupants. However, the distributional impacts of renovation incentives and the potential of fiscal policy to redistribute housing costs remain understudied. Dutch fiscal policy, favouring homeownership, offers a relevant context to evaluate how property taxation can boost renovation rates. The novelty of this paper resides in investigating the impact of two policies, the current direct subsidy and a proposal for a green tax, on both the financial viability of renovation and the subsequent distribution of housing costs. The proposed green tax combines energy efficiency and taxation of property revenue. We employ a model considering marginal costs of housing renovation, obtained from a government dataset, and marginal benefits, drawn from a hedonic regression. We assess the distributional impacts of different policy scenarios by examining changes in user costs across income deciles. Our findings indicate that existing renovation subsidies exacerbate the regressive distributional impacts resulting from the current housing taxation system in the Netherlands. Introducing energy-efficiency-linked property taxation can make homeownership fiscality less regressive while incentivising housing renovation. Ultimately, this study highlights the importance of incorporating housing affordability as a fundamental element in renovation policies to balance environmental and distributional objectives.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### Problems the Paper Attempts to Solve This paper aims to explore the impact of Dutch housing renovation policies on the distribution of housing costs among different income groups. Specifically, the study focuses on the following two aspects: 1. **Financial Feasibility of Existing Subsidies and Green Taxes**: The study evaluates the different impacts of current direct subsidies and proposed green taxes on the financial feasibility of housing renovations. Green taxes combine energy efficiency and property income tax. 2. **Distributional Effects of Housing Costs**: By analyzing changes in user costs under different policy scenarios, the study assesses the impact of these policies on the distribution of housing costs among different income groups. The study finds that existing renovation subsidies exacerbate the regressive effects of the current housing tax system in the Netherlands. Introducing property taxes linked to energy efficiency can reduce regressivity while incentivizing housing renovations. ### Research Background 1. **EU Energy Performance of Buildings Directive (EPBD)**: Since 2002, the EPBD has been central to building standards in EU member states. The directive has been revised multiple times, gradually expanding its scope and requiring member states to develop specific plans to phase out the least energy-efficient building stock. 2. **European Commission's Renovation Wave**: This initiative assesses budget solutions to support housing renovations in the EU, estimating that €275 billion in public and private investment is needed annually to achieve a 55% reduction in emissions by 2030. 3. **Dutch Housing Renovation Policies**: The Dutch government incentivizes housing renovations through a series of subsidies and low-interest loans. Since 2022, low-income families can also obtain 0% interest loans from the National Heat Fund. However, the Dutch household carbon tax is regressive, placing a heavier burden on low-income families. ### Research Methods 1. **Marginal Cost and Marginal Benefit Model**: The study employs the marginal cost and marginal benefit model proposed by Copiello and Donati (2021), based on Marshall's marginal utility theory. Marginal benefit (MB) refers to the increase in benefits from an additional unit of activity, while marginal cost (MC) refers to the increase in costs from an additional unit of activity. 2. **Hedonic Regression Analysis**: The study uses hedonic regression analysis to identify green premiums and, combined with the distribution analysis of housing costs, evaluates the distributional effects under different policy scenarios. ### Research Conclusions 1. **Regressivity of Existing Subsidies**: Existing housing renovation subsidies exacerbate the regressive effects of the current housing tax system, placing a heavier burden on low-income families. 2. **Potential Advantages of Green Taxes**: Introducing property taxes linked to energy efficiency can reduce regressivity while improving the financial feasibility of housing renovations. This tax mechanism can better balance environmental and social equity goals. 3. **Policy Recommendations**: The study emphasizes that housing affordability should be considered a fundamental element in designing housing renovation policies to balance environmental and distributional goals. ### Conclusion By analyzing the financial feasibility and distributional effects of Dutch housing renovation policies, this study reveals the shortcomings of existing subsidy policies and proposes the introduction of green taxes. This not only helps improve the financial feasibility of housing renovations but also reduces the regressive impact on housing costs, thereby promoting social equity.

Subsidies or green taxes? Evaluating the distributional effects of housing renovation policies among Dutch households

Well-being Effects of a Subsidy Retention Fund for Renovation of Dwellings of Locked-in Owners in Ghent

Energy retrofit as an answer to public health costs of fuel poverty in Lisbon social housing

Assessing the Role of Financial Incentives in Promoting Eco-Friendly Houses in the Lisbon Metropolitan Area—Portugal

Housing Tenure, Energy Consumption and the Split-Incentive Issue in Australia

Sustainable renovation of non-profit housing in the Netherlands: from projects to programs

Finnish energy renovation subsidies in multifamily apartment buildings: Lessons learnt and best practices

Assessment of Subsidization Strategies for Multi-Objective Optimization of Energy Efficiency Measures for Building Renovation at District Scale

Awareness and Utilization of Incentive Programs for Household Energy-Saving Renovations: Empirical Findings from Greece

Including Social Housing Residents in the Energy Transition: A Mixed-Method Case Study on Residents' Beliefs, Attitudes, and Motivation Toward Sustainable Energy Use in a Zero-Energy Building Renovation in the Netherlands

Reducing residential emissions: carbon pricing vs. subsidizing retrofits

Subsidies or cost-reflective energy tariffs? Alternative pathways for decarbonizing the residential sector and implications for cost efficiency

Energy renovation of single-family houses in Denmark utilising long-term financing based on equity

Sustainable building renovation in residential buildings: barriers and potential motivations in Norwegian culture

Embedding energy saving policies in Dutch social housing

The continued retreat of non-profit housing providers in the Netherlands

Renovation Results of Finnish Single-Family Renovation Subsidies: Oil Boiler Replacement with Heat Pumps

Landlords' accounts of retrofit: A relational approach in the private rented sector in England

Household budget restrictions as reason for staged retrofits: A case study in Spain

Energy Retrofitting in Public Housing and Fuel Poverty Reduction: Cost–Benefit Trade-Offs

Energy Efficiency Information and Valuation Practices in Rental Housing