House prices and the allocation of consumer credit

Mingzhu Tai

Abstract:It is well documented that the housing boom of the early 2000s fueled credit expansion among homeowners. Less attention has been paid to the effects of the housing boom on renters, who make up over 30% of US households. In this paper, I use detailed credit information from a sample of almost 500,000 US consumers to show that house price growth reduced renter credit access during the last housing boom. In particular, banks reduced non-mortgage credit supply when they expanded mortgage lending to homeowners. As a consequence, renters living in locations where banks had more (national) geographic exposure to the housing boom ended up borrowing less but defaulting more. The results are especially pronounced in locations with stronger credit market frictions, as measured by local banks’ mortgage retention probability and balance sheet liquidity, or bank competition in the local market. The effects of the housing boom on the borrowing and default behavior of renters persisted during the subsequent recession. This research suggests that policies affecting house prices and mortgage financing have broader implications for less well-off households that do not own a home. ∗Harvard Business School and Department of Economics, Harvard University. Email: mtai@fas.harvard.edu. I am especially grateful to Professors David Scharfstein, John Campbell, David Laibson, and Adi Sunderam for their generous advice and support during the entire progress of this project. I also thank participants at the Harvard Finance seminar for providing helpful comments.

Economics