Data-driven models for predicting compressive strength of 3D-printed fiber-reinforced concrete using interpretable machine learning algorithms
Muhammad Arif,Faizullah Jan,Aïssa Rezzoug,Muhammad Ali Afridi,Muhammad Luqman,Waseem Akhtar Khan,Marcin Kujawa,Hisham Alabduljabbar,Majid Khan
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cscm.2024.e03935
IF: 4.934
2024-11-08
Case Studies in Construction Materials
Abstract:3D printing technology is growing swiftly in the construction sector due to its numerous benefits, such as intricate designs, quicker construction, waste reduction, environmental friendliness, cost savings, and enhanced safety. Nevertheless, optimizing the concrete mix for 3D printing is a challenging task due to the numerous factors involved, requiring extensive experimentation. Therefore, this study used three machine learning techniques, including Gene Expression Programming (GEP), Multi-Expression Programming (MEP), and Decision Tree (DT), to forecast the compressive strength of 3D printed fiber-reinforced concrete (3DP-FRC). The dataset comprises 299 data points with sixteen variables gathered from experimental research studies. For training the model, 70 % of the dataset was used, while the remaining 30 % was reserved for model testing. Several statistical metrics were utilized to evaluate the accuracy and applicability of the models. In addition, SHapley Additive exPlanations (SHAP), partial dependence plots, and individual conditional expectations approach were employed for the interpretability of the models. The proposed GEP, MEP, and DT models indicated enhanced efficacy, exhibiting correlation coefficient (R) score s of 0.996, 0.987, and 0.990, with mean absolute errors (MAE) of 1.029, 4.832, and 2.513, respectively. Overall, the established GEP model demonstrated exceptional performance compared to MEP and DT, showcasing high prediction precision in assessing the strength of 3DP-FRC. Moreover, a simple empirical formulation has been devised using GEP to predict the compressive strength, offering a simplified and efficient approach for predicting 3DP-FRC strength. The SHAP approach identified water, silica fume, fiber diameter, curing age, and loading directions as leading controlling parameter s in predicting strength of 3DP-FRC. In summary, the proposed models can potentially minimize both the computational workload and the need for experimental trials in formulating the mixed design of 3D-printed concrete.
construction & building technology,materials science, multidisciplinary,engineering, civil