Straightforward Assessment of Wettability Changes by Washburn Capillary Rise: Toward a Screening Tool for Selecting Water Compositions for Improved Oil Recovery

Valérie Molinier,Laura Pauliet,Alexandra Klimenko,Nicolas Passade-Boupat,Maurice Bourrel,Valérie Molinier
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1021/acsomega.3c08630
IF: 4.1
2024-02-20
ACS Omega
Abstract:Evaluating the wettability state of reservoir rocks is key for understanding and optimizing waterflooding and improved oil recovery techniques that imply the use of low-salinity water. Aside from established petrophysical techniques, such as Amott imbibition tests, we evaluated the Washburn capillary rise method as a low-cost, easy-to-implement, and rapid screening tool for probing the wettability state of rock samples. The well-known limitations of this method are discussed and circumvented. We...
chemistry, multidisciplinary
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
### Problems the paper attempts to solve The paper aims to evaluate the Washburn capillary rise method as a low - cost, easy - to - implement and rapid screening tool for exploring the changes in reservoir rock wettability. Specifically, the researchers hope to evaluate the effects of different treatments on the wettability state of materials by measuring the capillary rise of two liquids (brine and n - octane). The wettability state is quantified by the adhesion tension of brine to the solid. The higher the adhesion tension, the more hydrophilic the sample. The study also explores the change in wettability to a more hydrophilic state after treating oil - wet samples with low - salinity water or surfactant solutions. ### Background and motivation 1. **Secondary oil recovery**: After a period of natural or artificial lifting of hydrocarbon production, most oil fields enter the so - called "secondary" oil recovery period, during which gas or water is injected into the reservoir to displace oil. Usually, the produced water is reinjected, but for practical reasons, especially in offshore oil fields, seawater is also injected. 2. **Low - salinity water flooding**: Laboratory and field studies have shown that injecting seawater can improve oil recovery compared to reinjecting produced water. This has prompted researchers to explore the influence of the salinity of injected water on oil production and develop a new enhanced oil recovery method, known as "low - salinity water flooding" or more generally "chemically tuned water flooding". 3. **Wettability change**: Low - salinity water flooding causes the rock wettability to change from oil - wet or mixed - wet to a more hydrophilic state. This change is usually attributed to the adsorption of organic compounds from crude oil onto the rock surface, and low - salinity water flooding will cause partial desorption of these compounds. The injection of low concentrations of surfactants can also change wettability by forming ion pairs or adsorbing on the rock surface. ### Research methods 1. **Washburn capillary rise method**: The researchers evaluated the effectiveness of the Washburn capillary rise method as a rapid screening tool. This method determines the contact angle of a liquid on a solid by measuring the change in the mass of the liquid spontaneously infiltrating the sample over time. 2. **Experimental design**: Two carbonate rocks (Tacon and Edwards White) and Sikaisol silica sand were used in the experiment. The samples were aged by contact with crude oil - released water or directly with crude oil, and then these samples were treated with brine or surfactant solutions of different compositions, and then Washburn capillary rise experiments were carried out. ### Key conclusions 1. **Effectiveness of the method**: The Washburn capillary rise method has been proven to be a rapid and reliable method for screening wettability changes. This method can be completed within 1 - 10 minutes, has good reproducibility, and can screen out multiple brine compositions within a reasonable time. 2. **Wettability change**: By measuring the adhesion tension of brine, the wettability change of the sample can be quantified. When the sample is in contact with crude oil or its released water, the oil - wettability increases; while after treatment with low - salinity brine or surfactant solutions, the water - wettability increases. 3. **Application prospects**: This method can be used as an effective tool to identify the most favorable brine composition for further testing using more time - consuming techniques (such as Amott tests and core displacement experiments). ### Formulas and theoretical basis 1. **Washburn equation**: \[ m=\sqrt{\frac{2\gamma\cos\theta}{\eta}}\cdot c\cdot\sqrt{t} \] where \(m\) is the mass of the liquid rising in the powder bed (kg), \(c\) is the capillary constant (\(m^{5}\)), \(\rho\) is the liquid density (\(kg/m^{3}\)), \(\gamma\) is the liquid surface tension (\(mN/m\)), \(\theta\) is the contact angle of the liquid on the solid (\(^{\circ}\)), \(\eta\) is the liquid viscosity (\(mPa\cdot s\)), and \(t\) is the time (s). 2. **Adhesion tension**: \[ \Delta\gamma = \gamma\cos\theta \] The adhesion tension \(\Delta\gamma\) represents the adhesion force of the liquid to the solid. As the adhesion tension increases, the degree of wetting of the solid by the liquid increases. 3. **Capillary constant**: \[ c=\frac{