Abstract:In this study, we examine introductory physics students' ability to perform analogical reasoning between two isomorphic problems which employ the same underlying physics principles but have different surface features. Three hundred and eighty two students from a calculus-based and an algebra-based introductory physics course were asked to learn from a solved problem provided and take advantage of what they learned from it to solve another isomorphic problem (which we call the quiz problem). The solved problem provided has two sub-problems while the quiz problem has three sub-problems, which is known to be challenging for introductory students from previous research. In addition to the solved problem, students also received extra scaffolding supports that were intended to help them discern and exploit the underlying similarities of the isomorphic solved and quiz problems. The results suggest that students had great difficulty in transferring what they learned from a 2-step problem to a 3-step problem. Although most students were able to learn from the solved problem to some extent with the scaffolding provided and invoke the relevant principles in the quiz problem, they were not necessarily able to apply the principles correctly. We also conducted think-aloud interviews with 6 introductory students in order to understand in-depth the difficulties they had and explore strategies to provide better scaffolding. The interviews suggest that students often superficially mapped the principles employed in the solved problem to the quiz problem without necessarily understanding the governing conditions underlying each principle and examining the applicability of the principle in the new situation in an in-depth manner. Findings suggest that more scaffolding is needed to help students in transferring from a two-step problem to a three step problem and applying the physics principles appropriately.

Difficult Problems Having Easy Solutions

Kinematics on oblique axes

The Brachistochrone: An Excellent Problem for All Levels of Physics Students

Obstacles to Mathematization in Introductory Physics

Blending physical knowledge with mathematical form in physics problem solving

Exercises are problems too: implications for teaching problem-solving in introductory physics courses

Using Isomorphic Problems to Learn Introductory Physics

Assessing Student Expertise in Introductory Physics with Isomorphic Problems, Part I: Performance on Non-intuitive Problem Pair from Introductory Physics

When physical intuition fails

Learning Mathematics through incorrect Problems

Using an Isomorphic Problem Pair to Learn Introductory Physics: Transferring from a Two-step Problem to a Three-step Problem

Fun Problems in Geometry and Beyond

A comparison of Olympians' and regular students' approaches and successes in solving counterintuitive dynamics problems

A non-standard approach to introduce simple harmonic motion

Challenges in Analogical Reasoning

An equitable and effective approach to introductory mechanics

Nonlinear nonholonomic systems: a simple approach and various examples

Assessing Student Expertise in Introductory Physics with Isomorphic Problems, Part II: Effect of Some Potential Factors on Problem Solving and Transfer

Problem-solving a lesson from relativity in physics education

Problem Solving and the Use of Math in Physics Courses

What we talk about when we talk about physics problem solving