Abstract:It is well-known that introductory physics students often have alternative conceptions that are inconsistent with established physical principles and concepts. Invoking alternative conceptions in quantitative problem-solving process can derail the entire process. In order to help students solve quantitative problems involving strong alternative conceptions correctly, appropriate scaffolding support can be helpful. The goal of this study is to examine how different scaffolding supports involving analogical problem solving influence introductory physics students' performance on a target quantitative problem in a situation where many students' solution process is derailed due to alternative conceptions. Three different scaffolding supports were designed and implemented in calculus-based and algebra-based introductory physics courses to evaluate the level of scaffolding needed to help students learn from an analogical problem that is similar in the underlying principles but for which the problem solving process is not derailed by alternative conceptions. We found that for the quantitative problem involving strong alternative conceptions, simply guiding students to work through the solution of the analogical problem first was not enough to help most students discern the similarity between the two problems. However, if additional scaffolding supports that directly helped students examine and repair their knowledge elements involving alternative conceptions were provided, students were more likely to discern the underlying similarities between the problems and avoid getting derailed by alternative conceptions when solving the targeted problem. We also found that some scaffolding supports were more effective in the calculus-based course than in the algebra-based course. This finding emphasizes the fact that appropriate scaffolding support must be determined via research in order to be effective.

Using Isomorphic Problems to Learn Introductory Physics

Using an Isomorphic Problem Pair to Learn Introductory Physics: Transferring from a Two-step Problem to a Three-step Problem

Challenges in Analogical Reasoning

Effect of Scaffolding on Helping Introductory Physics Students Solve Quantitative Problems Involving Strong Alternative Conceptions

Assessing Student Expertise in Introductory Physics with Isomorphic Problems, Part I: Performance on Non-intuitive Problem Pair from Introductory Physics

Assessing Student Expertise in Introductory Physics with Isomorphic Problems, Part II: Effect of Some Potential Factors on Problem Solving and Transfer

Using Analogical Problem Solving with Different Scaffolding Supports to Learn about Friction

Blending physical knowledge with mathematical form in physics problem solving

Coupling Conceptual and Quantitative Problems to Develop Expertise in Introductory Physics Students

Instructional Strategies that Foster Effective Problem-Solving

An equitable and effective approach to introductory mechanics

Challenges in designing appropriate scaffolding to improve students' representational consistency: The case of a Gauss's law problem

Obstacles to Mathematization in Introductory Physics

Exercises are problems too: implications for teaching problem-solving in introductory physics courses

Helping students become proficient problem solvers Part II: An example from waves

Interactive video tutorials for enhancing problem solving, reasoning, and meta-cognitive skills of introductory physics students

Improving student's problem-solving ability as well as conceptual understanding without sacrificing the physics content of a class

Surveying Graduate Students' Attitudes and Approaches to Problem Solving

Conceptual problem solving in high school physics

When physical intuition fails

Comparing student performance on a multi-attempt asynchronous assessment to a single-attempt synchronous assessment in introductory level physics