From theory to practice: a roadmap for applying dual-process theory in design cognition research

Emma Lawrie,Meagan Flus,Alison Olechowski,Laura Hay,Andrew Wodehouse

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/09544828.2024.2336837

2024-04-03

Journal of Engineering Design

Abstract:Dual-process theory categorises cognition into two types of processing: Type 1 which is intuitive, autonomous processing, and Type 2 which is reflective processing that burdens limited executive cognitive resources (i.e. working memory). A recent call for increased theory-driven research in the field of design has led to a framing of dual-process theory as a foundation for design research. This research note presents a roadmap for future dual-process theory-driven design research outlining three main stages: defining dual-process theory constructs, determining research focus, and selecting research methods. Across these stages, we offer a conceptualisation of dual-process theory for design researchers, outlining the main concepts of the theory. We then present how a research study design must consider the nature of design problems (complex, ill-structured, ambiguous), designers, and the practice of design. Finally, we outline the main methods employed in dual-process theory research: behavioural, physiological, and self-report measures, suggesting ways to adapt such methods to design contexts. Ultimately, this work presents how dual-process theory may connect with theories of cognition often considered in design and offers a path forward for dual-process theory-driven design research.

engineering, multidisciplinary

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### The Problem the Paper Attempts to Address

This paper attempts to address the challenges of a lack of theory-driven and methodological consistency in design cognition research. Specifically:

1. **Lack of Theoretical Foundation**: The field of design cognition research lacks a common ontological foundation, leading to inconsistent research methods and unclear research practice norms.
2. **Need for Theory-Driven Research**: There is an increasing call within the design research field for theory-driven research to enhance the rigor of studies.
3. **Application of Dual Process Theory**: Dual Process Theory (DPT) has been widely recognized in cognitive psychology and can serve as a theoretical framework for design cognition research. However, applying this theory to the design field presents challenges, such as incomplete understanding of theoretical principles, selection of different models, and their applicability.

To address these challenges, the paper proposes a roadmap for applying Dual Process Theory in design cognition research, which includes three main stages:

1. **Defining the Constructs of Dual Process Theory**: Understanding the basic principles of Dual Process Theory, selecting an appropriate DPT model, and defining the characteristics and related factors of Type 1 and Type 2 processing.
2. **Identifying Research Focus**: Considering design theory and design practice, defining the specific focus of the research, including factors such as the experience level of designers and team collaboration.
3. **Selecting Research Methods**: Choosing suitable design cognition research methods, including behavioral measurements, self-reports, and physiological measurements, while ensuring to avoid common theoretical misunderstandings.

Through these three stages, the paper aims to provide a systematic approach to design cognition research to improve consistency and comparability of studies, and to promote the transfer and synthesis of knowledge.