Abstract:Background The cocreation of eHealth solutions with potential users, or co-design, can help make the solution more acceptable. However, the co-design research approach requires substantial investment, and projects are not always fruitful. Researchers have provided guidelines for the co-design approach, but these are either applicable only in specific situations or not supported by empirical data. Ways to optimize the experience of the co-design process from the point of view of the participants are also missing. Scientific literature in the co-design field generally provides an extrinsic description of the experience of participants in co-design projects. Objective We addressed this issue by describing a co-design project and focusing on the participants’ experiences looking at what was significant from their point of view. Methods We used a qualitative situated cognitive anthropology approach for this study. Data were collected on a co-design research project that aimed to support the help-seeking process of caregivers of functionally dependent older adults. The methodology was based on the perspective of experience by Dewey and used the course-of-action theoretical and methodological framework. Data collection was conducted in 2 phases: observation of participants and recording of sessions and participant self-confrontation interviews using the session recordings. We interviewed 27% (20/74) of the participants. We analyzed the data through nonexclusive emerging categorization of themes using the constant comparative method. Results In total, 5 emerging themes were identified. The perception of extrinsic constraints and the effects of the situation was central and the most important theme, affecting other themes (frustrating interactions with others, learning together, destabilization, and getting personal benefits). Co-occurrences between codes allowed for a visual and narrative understanding of what was significant for the participants during this project. The results highlighted the importance of the role of the research team in preparing and moderating the sessions. They also provided a detailed description of the interactions between participants during the sessions, which is a core aspect of the co-design approach. There were positive and negative aspects of the participants’ experiences during this co-design project. Reflecting on our results, we provided potential affordances to shape the experience of participants in co-design. Conclusions Potential users are an essential component of the co-design research approach. Researchers and designers should seek to offer these users a positive and contributory experience to encourage participation in further co-design initiatives. Future research should explore how the proposed affordances influence the success of the intervention.

Dynamic aspects of individual design activities. A cognitive ergonomics viewpoint

Conception individuelle et collective. Approche de l'ergonomie cognitive [Individual and Collective Design. The Cognitive-Ergonomics Approach]

Designing as Construction of Representations: A Dynamic Viewpoint in Cognitive Design Research

A participant-observer study of ergonomics in engineering design: how constraints drive design process

Design: one, but in different forms

Designer behaviour and activity: an industrial observation method

Evocation and elaboration of solutions: Different types of problem-solving actions. An empirical study on the design of an aerospace artifact

Empathy Enabled by Critical Design - A New Tool in the Universal Design Toolbox

Cognitive Effort in Collective Software Design: Methodological Perspectives in Cognitive Ergonomics

"Why should I care?": Understanding technology developers' design mindsets in relation to prospective work design

User Experience of the Co-design Research Approach in eHealth: Activity Analysis With the Course-of-Action Framework

Designing Ergonomic Data Tools for Designers

Both Generic Design and Different Forms of Designing

L'analyse de l'expertise du point de vue de l'ergonomie cognitive

The role of anthropometry in designing for sustainability

Introducing ergonomics requirements in the eco-design of energy-related products from users' behaviour approach

In Search for Design Elements: A New Perspective for Employing Ethnography in Human-Computer Interaction Design Research

Knowing, reasoning and visualizing in industrial design

Structured to Succeed? Strategy Dynamics in Engineering Systems Design and Their Effect on Collective Performance

Function and form of gestures in a collaborative design meeting

Psychology of Design