Abstract:Spatial thinking is ubiquitous in design. Design education across all age groups encompasses a range of spatially challenging activities, such as forming and modifying mental representations of ideas, and visualizing the scenarios of design prototypes being used. While extensive research has examined the cognitive processes of spatial thinking and their relationships to science, technology, engineering, and mathematics learning, there remains a knowledge gap regarding the specific spatial thinking processes needed for open-ended problems, which may differ from those assessed in close-ended, analytical spatial tasks. To address this gap, we used educational design-based research to develop a nature-inspired, design-by-analogy project and investigate the spatial thinking processes of young, novice designers. 16 children from an international school in the Netherlands participated in this five-week design project. Multimodal evidence from classroom recordings and children's design works were triangulated to offer insight into the key spatial thinking processes involved in their creation of nature-inspired, analogy-based design prototypes. Our results revealed spatial thinking processes that might not align with those assessed in conventional spatial tests and may be unique to design or open-ended problem-solving. These processes include abstracting spatial features to infer form-function relationships, retrieving a range of relevant visual information from memory, developing multiple possible analogical matches based on spatial features and relationships, elaborating and iterating on the design concepts and representations to make creative and suitable solutions for the design challenge, as well as visualizing design prototypes in practical usage scenarios. By highlighting the nuanced differences between spatial thinking in open-ended, divergent thinking tasks and conventional spatial tasks that demand single correct solutions, our research contributes to a deeper understanding of how children utilize spatial thinking in design and open-ended problem-solving contexts. Furthermore, this case study offers practical implications for scaffolding children's analogical reasoning and nurturing their spatial thinking in design education.

Evocation and elaboration of solutions: Different types of problem-solving actions. An empirical study on the design of an aerospace artifact

Dynamic aspects of individual design activities. A cognitive ergonomics viewpoint

Solution driven versus problem driven design: strategies and outcomes

PROBLEM SOLVING BEHAVIOR EMPLOYED IN APARTMENT INTERIOR WORKS DESIGN USING INTERACTIVE EVOLUTIONARY COMPUTATION

The complementary roles of intuition and logic in creative design ideation.

Improving Executive Functions Using the Engineering Design Process: A Peer-Mediated Problem-Solving Approach for Autistic Adolescents

Investigating the role of spatial thinking in children's design ideation through an open-ended design-by-analogy challenge

Development of an expert system-based experimental frame for modeling of manufacturing systems

Analysis of Problem Decomposition Strategies of Novice Industrial Designers Using Network-Based Cognitive Maps

Spontaneous decision-making behavior: correlation of electrodermal activities to an architecture design time-problem

Impasse-Driven problem solving: The multidimensional nature of feeling stuck

Examining the Design Actions and Reasoning Factors That Impact Design Performance

Designing as Construction of Representations: A Dynamic Viewpoint in Cognitive Design Research

Does Metacognition Matter in Creative Problem‐Solving? A Mixed‐Methods Analysis of Writing

A Comparative Analysis of Student Perceptions of Recommendations for Engagement in Design Processes

Advancing engineering design problem-exploring practice: interviews with industry professionals

Paving the Way to Eureka—Introducing “Dira” as an Experimental Paradigm to Observe the Process of Creative Problem Solving

Unconscious processing of prototype heuristics in scientific innovation problem-solving

A model of the mechanical design process based on empirical data

ENHANCING ENGINEERING CREATIVITY WITH AUTOMATED FORMULATION OF ELEMENTARY SOLUTION PRINCIPLES

Experimentally Evaluating Communicative Strategies: The Effect of the Task