Experimental investigation on thermal runaway propagation of large format lithium ion battery modules with two cathodes

Zonghou Huang,Xin Li,Qingshan Wang,Qiangling Duan,Yan Li,Lina Li,Qingsong Wang
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijheatmasstransfer.2021.121077
IF: 5.2
2021-06-01
International Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer
Abstract:<p>LiNi<sub>x</sub>Co<sub>y</sub>Mn<sub>z</sub>O<sub>2</sub> (NCM) and LiFePO<sub>4</sub> (LFP) batteries are the two most widely employed in vehicles and energy storage stations, however, fire accidents related to them occurs frequently. A comparative analysis on the thermal runaway (TR) propagation behavior of NCM and LFP module are conducted in this work. Results indicate that intense jet fire and combustion behavior occurs in the NCM module, only a considerable amount of white smoke is observed in the LFP module. Generally, the duration time (<em>t<sub>d</sub></em>) of TR and the maximum temperature (<em>T<sub>max</sub></em>) of the NCM LIB are significantly higher than those of the LFP LIB. Compared with NCM modules, LFP modules are significantly less likely to suffer from TR propagation. Once TR propagation occurs in LFP module, the TR propagation in a single LFP LIB and LFP module is less aggressive and risk than in the NCM LIB and NCM module, respectively. And the TR propagation mechanism of the LFP and NCM modules are comparatively analyzed. Besides, the comparative analysis of gas production and gas toxicity of large format NCM and LFP module during TR propagation is revealed for the first time, which is very meaningful for the further evacuation and rescue of large-format LIB fires. It is found that the total mass of ejected combustible gases (including H<sub>2</sub>, CH<sub>4</sub>, C<sub>2</sub>H<sub>4</sub>, C<sub>3</sub>H<sub>6</sub>, CO) per failed cell number of the NCM module are much higher than that of the LFP module, which is determined to be 21.09 g and 4.17 g for the NCM and LFP module, respectively. Besides, the results calculated by the <em>FED</em> and <em>FEC</em> models demonstrate that the toxicity of ejected gases from NCM module is greater than that of the LFP module. This work present in detail the TR propagation characteristics of large-format NCM and LFP modules, which can provide valuable information for the safety design of lithium-ion batteries.</p>
engineering, mechanical,thermodynamics,mechanics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to study and compare the behavioral differences of large - sized lithium - ion battery modules with two different cathode materials (LiFePO₄, abbreviated as LFP, and LiNiₓCoᵧMnzO₂, abbreviated as NCM) during the thermal runaway propagation process. Specifically, the research aims to: 1. **Evaluate the characteristics of thermal runaway propagation**: Through experimental research, understand the characteristics such as the propagation speed, duration, and temperature change of LFP and NCM battery modules after triggering thermal runaway. 2. **Analyze gas generation and toxicity**: For the first time, comparatively analyze the total amount of gas generated and its toxicity during the thermal runaway propagation of large - sized LFP and NCM battery modules, providing data support for future fire evacuation and rescue. 3. **Explore the mechanism of thermal runaway propagation**: Reveal the differences in the internal mechanisms of these two battery modules during the thermal runaway propagation process, including heat transfer paths and reaction rates, etc. 4. **Provide a reference for safety design**: Through detailed data and theoretical support, provide guidance for the safety design of lithium - ion battery modules in electric vehicles and energy storage systems. ### Key issues - **The severity of thermal runaway propagation**: The research found that the NCM module exhibits violent combustion phenomena, while the LFP module mainly shows a large amount of white smoke, and the thermal runaway propagation of the NCM module is more violent. - **Gas generation and toxicity**: The total mass of combustible gas generated by the NCM module is significantly higher than that of the LFP module, which are 21.09 grams and 4.17 grams respectively. In addition, according to the FED and FEC models, the gas toxicity released by the NCM module is also higher. - **Thermal runaway propagation time**: The thermal runaway propagation time of the LFP module is significantly longer than that of the NCM module, indicating that the LFP module has an advantage in terms of safety. ### Conclusion This research, through experiments and data analysis, shows in detail the different behaviors of LFP and NCM battery modules during the thermal runaway propagation process, emphasizes the safety performance advantages of LFP batteries, and provides an important reference basis for future research and applications.