Comment on "Observation of the e/3 fractionally charged Laughlin quasiparticles" and "Direct Observation of Fractional Charge"

V.J. Goldman

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.cond-mat/9708041

1997-08-06

Abstract:comment on <a class="link-https" data-arxiv-id="cond-mat/9706300" href="https://arxiv.org/abs/cond-mat/9706300">cond-mat/9706300</a>7 and <a class="link-https" data-arxiv-id="cond-mat/9707289" href="https://arxiv.org/abs/cond-mat/9707289">cond-mat/9707289</a>

Mesoscale and Nanoscale Physics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problems that this paper attempts to solve mainly focus on clarifying misunderstandings and inaccurate statements regarding previous fractional - charge measurement experiments. Specifically, in 1995, the author Vladimir J. Goldman and his collaborators directly observed fractional charges \( \frac{e}{3} \) and \( \frac{e}{5} \) for the first time through antidot tunneling experiments. However, later, other research teams (such as Franklin et al.) interpreted these results differently and claimed that they "reproduced" Goldman and Su's experiments.

### Main problems:
1. **Clarifying misunderstandings**: Goldman et al. pointed out that Franklin et al.'s experiments did not truly reproduce their experimental conditions, especially because Franklin et al.'s samples did not have a macroscopic global back - gate, which was a key component in Goldman et al.'s experiments for generating a uniform electric field. Therefore, Franklin et al.'s experiments could not measure the same physical quantities as Goldman et al.
2. **Explaining experimental differences**: Goldman et al. emphasized that their experiments directly measured the coupling between particles and a uniform electric field, that is, the charge of particles (in Coulombs), rather than the filling factor, which is a dimensionless number. Therefore, Franklin et al.'s discussion of the filling factor does not apply to Goldman et al.'s experiments.
3. **Confirming the first observation**: Goldman et al. reiterated that they directly observed and accurately measured fractional charges \( \frac{e}{3} \) and \( \frac{e}{5} \) for the first time, and this result has been widely recognized in the theoretical community.

### Formula summary:
- Measurement of fractional charge: \( q=\frac{e}{m} \), where \( e \) is the electron charge and \( m \) is the integer corresponding to the fractional filling factor.
- Filling factor: \( \nu = \frac{n_s}{n_\phi} \), where \( n_s \) is the areal density of the two - dimensional electron system and \( n_\phi \) is the magnetic flux quantum density.

Through this paper, the author aims to correct the scientific community's understanding of fractional - charge measurement experiments and ensure that their original contributions are correctly recognized and cited.