Developing compassionate communities through Community- Oriented Integrated Practice
Paul Thomas
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3399/bjgp24x739293
2024-09-01
British Journal of General Practice
Abstract:The Royal College of General Practitioners general election manifesto 2024 reminds us that: 'GPs work at the heart of their communities, striving to provide comprehensive and equitable care for everyone ... ' Julian Tudor Hart would have approved. In 1961 he became a GP in Glyncorrwg, a small mining town in the South Wales Valleys. His work, radical at the time, contributed to the present expectation that primary care should be central to compassionate communities. He pointed out that an engineering/mechanistic approach to medical science prevents GPs from doing a good job, contributing to the present NHS crisis: 'The misrepresentation of medical science as the solid, simple, Newtonian certainty of engineering ... has misled not only the public, but the profession itself.' Before he became King of England, Prince Charles said a similar thing: 'It is the way we see the world that is ultimately at fault ... far too firmly framed by a mechanistic approach to science ... [that] assumes authority beyond the area it is capable of considering ... ' Newton's 17th century thinking has been romanticised as an apple falling on his head. This linear, atomised image of how the world works is attractive — it makes everything seem identifiable, controllable, and predictable. It was given a boost in the 19th century by Auguste Comte, who proposed an approach to inquiry called positivism (laboratory research), and William Osler in the 20th century, who advocated its use in medicine (evidence-based medicine). Hence the term 'medicalisation' being used to imply mechanistic dehumanisation. Linear, atomised, 'medical' thinking is needed — some things need precise identification and targeted action. But, on its own, it leads to linear, atomised thinking about everything else — carrots and sticks, hierarchies and priorities, conflict and blame. It looks at the world through a pinhole camera ...
medicine, general & internal,primary health care