Books: Fighting for the Soul of General Practice: the Algorithm Will See You Now

Andrew Papanikitas

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3399/bjgp24x739605

2024-09-27

British Journal of General Practice

Abstract:Rupal Shah, Jens Foell Intellect, 2024, PB, 258pp, £19.95, 978-1789388398 In this remarkable book, two GPs offer a narrative account of the daily realities of British urban general practice and reflect on the unsettled philosophy, psychology, and phenomenology of GP life. Rupal Shah and Jens Foell reflect on their authentic stories with scholarship and cultural memes. We are invited to empathise with the moral distress they experience as GPs attempting to be human in an increasingly computerised and standardised healthcare system. The professional environment is one of austerity combined with a system that is bureaucratic and target-driven. The authors describe GPs as 'street level bureaucrats' in that we simultaneously enact the dictates of 'tyrannical officialdom' while addressing the needs of our clients. The text feels like a conversation — of course, bureaucracy exists as a safeguard against exploitation by those in power, they tell us while raging against the machine — and the authors caution the reader that life and language are nuanced. The reflections on each case blend practical wisdom with scholarship that ranges from the intellectual heroes of general practice, such as Julian Tudor Hart and David Armstrong, to the philosophers, such as Thomas Hobbes and Miranda Fricker, whose work describes and/or underpins our social reality. The memes used ...

medicine, general & internal,primary health care