Abstract:Introduction: An objective of undergraduate medical education is to teach students how to think like physicians through a process called clinical reasoning. Currently, clerkship directors often feel that students enter their clinical years with a marginal comprehension of clinical reasoning concepts; instruction in this area could be improved. Although there have been previous educational studies assessing curricular interventions to improve the instruction of clinical reasoning, it is not yet known what happens at an individual level between an instructor and a small group of students in the teaching of clinical reasoning. This research will identify how clinical reasoning is being taught in a longitudinal clinical reasoning course. Methods: The Introduction to Clinical Reasoning course is a 15-month-long case-based course held in the preclinical curriculum of the USU. Individual sessions involve small-group learning with approximately seven students per group. Throughout the academic year of 2018-2019, 10 of these sessions were videotaped and transcribed. All participants provided informed consent. A thematic analysis was performed using a constant comparative approach. Transcripts were analyzed until thematic sufficiency was reached. Results: Over 300 pages of text were analyzed; new themes ceased to be identified after the eighth session. Topics included obstetrics, general pediatric issues, jaundice, and chest pain; these sessions were taught either by attendings, fellows, or fourth-year medical students with attending supervision. The thematic analysis revealed themes associated with clinical reasoning processes, themes associated with knowledge organization, and a theme associated with clinical reasoning in the military. The clinical reasoning process themes included problem list construction and refinement, differential diagnosis, naming and defending a leading diagnosis, and clinical reasoning heuristics. The knowledge organization themes included illness script development and refinement and semantic competence. The final theme was military relevant care. Conclusions: In individual teaching sessions, preceptors emphasized problem lists, differential diagnoses, and leading diagnoses in a course designed to strengthen diagnostic reasoning in preclerkship medical students. The use of illness scripts was more often implicitly used rather than explicitly stated, and students used these sessions to use and apply new vocabularies related to a clinical presentation. Instruction in clinical reasoning could be improved by encouraging faculty to provide further context to their thinking, by encouraging the comparing and contrasting of illness scripts, and by using a shared vocabulary for clinical reasoning. Limitations of this study include that it was done in the context of a clinical reasoning course and that it was done at a military medical school, which may limit generalizability. Future studies could determine if faculty development could improve the frequency of references to the clinical reasoning processes that could improve student readiness for clerkship.

Thinking more wisely: using the Socratic method to develop critical thinking skills amongst healthcare students

The use of the Socratic inquiry to facilitate critical thinking in nursing education

Training Medical Students' Critical Thinking in Clinical Practice

Socratic Questioning: A Philosophical Approach in Developing Critical Thinking Skills

Using Socratic Questioning Strategy to Enhance Critical Thinking Skill of Elementary School Students

Development of critical thinking skills in human anatomy and physiology

Critical thinking pedagogical practices in medical education: a systematic review

A novel approach to clinical thinking training for medical students: the combined World Café discussion and case-based learning experience introduction

Training on Clinical Thinking to Improve Clinicians' Skills of Disease Diagnosis and Management

Using Socratic Questioning to Promote Students’ Critical Thinking Skills

Clinical reasoning in real-world practice: a primer for medical trainees and practitioners

Using an experiential learning model to teach clinical reasoning theory and cognitive bias: an evaluation of a first-year medical student curriculum

Using Nobel Prize case-based learning in Medical Immunology to cultivate critical thinking dispositions for medical undergraduates

Clinical Reasoning in Medical Education: A Primer for Medical Students

Teaching Students How to Think: A Longitudinal Qualitative Study of Preclerkship Clinical Reasoning Instruction

Putting Socrates back in Socratic method: Theory-based debriefing in the nursing classroom

The effects of Socratic questioning on critical thinking in web-based collaborative learning

The relationship and influencing factors of critical thinking and medical ethical decision-making among pediatric medical students

Teaching clinical reasoning: principles from the literature to help improve instruction from the classroom to the bedside

Preceptor questioning and student critical thinking

Impacts of Socratic questioning on moral reasoning of nursing students