Heinz-Olaf Muller,K. A. Chao
Abstract:The qualities of electron refrigeration by means of tunnel junctions between superconducting and normal--metal electrodes are studied theoretically. A suitable approximation of the basic expression for the heat current across those tunnel junctions allows the investigation of several features of the device such as its optimal bias voltage, its maximal heat current, its optimal working point, and the maximally gained temperature reduction. Fortunately, the obtained results can be compared with those of a recent experiment.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is the theoretical study of achieving electron refrigeration between superconductors and normal - metal electrodes through tunnel junctions. Specifically, the authors explored how to use these tunnel junctions to reduce the electron temperature to the sub - Kelvin range and studied some key characteristics in this process, such as the optimal bias voltage, the maximum heat flow, the optimal operating point, and the maximum temperature drop.
### Main problems and goals of the paper
1. **Working principle of the electron refrigerator**:
- By applying an appropriate bias voltage \( V \) between the superconductor - insulator - normal - metal (SIN) and normal - metal - insulator - superconductor (NIS) junctions, only high - energy (hot) electrons can leave the intermediate island region, while low - energy (cold) electrons can enter the island region. This selective transmission leads to the cooling of electrons.
2. **Optimization of bias voltage and heat flow**:
- The method for determining the optimal bias voltage \( V_{\text{opt}} \) was studied, and the change of the corresponding heat flow \( P(V_{\text{opt}}) \) under different temperature conditions was analyzed. Equation (4) is the main result of this paper, which describes the relationship between heat flow and bias voltage:
\[
P(V) \approx \frac{\Delta^2}{2e^2R} \left\{ [K_0(\gamma_N \Delta) + K_2(\gamma_N \Delta)] \cosh(\gamma_N eV) - K_0(\gamma_S \Delta) - K_2(\gamma_S \Delta) \right\} - \frac{\Delta eV \sinh(\gamma_N eV)}{e^2R K_1(\gamma_N \Delta)}
\]
where \( K_\nu(z) \) is the modified Bessel function, \(\gamma_N = \frac{1}{2k_B T_N \ln 2}\), \(\gamma_S = \frac{1}{2k_B T_S \ln 2}\).
3. **Experimental verification and theoretical comparison**:
- The authors compared the theoretical results with the recent experimental data and found that they have good consistency within a certain temperature range. In particular, at low temperatures, the theoretical model successfully predicted the change trends of electron temperature and heat flow in the experiment.
4. **Influence of non - equilibrium effects**:
- At very low temperatures, the authors noticed that there are deviations between the experimental results and the theoretical predictions, which may be caused by non - equilibrium effects (such as the deviation of the electron energy distribution from the Fermi distribution). Therefore, further research on these non - equilibrium effects is an interesting open problem.
### Conclusion
Through the theoretical study of tunnel - junction electron refrigerators, the authors not only obtained a closed - form heat - flow formula but also explored its performance characteristics under different working conditions. In particular, they found the universal ratio \( T_{N,\text{opt}}/T_{S,\text{opt}} \approx 0.3 \) between the electron temperature and the lead temperature at the optimal operating point and compared it with the experimental results. In addition, the authors pointed out that at very low temperatures, the influence of non - equilibrium effects on the system behavior is worthy of further study.