Influence of photon-assisted tunneling on heat flow in a normal metal - superconductor tunnel junction

N. B. Kopnin,F. Taddei,J. P. Pekola,F. Giazotto

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevB.77.104517

2008-03-21

Abstract:We have investigated theoretically the influence of an AC drive on heat transport in a hybrid normal metal - superconductor tunnel junction in the photon-assisted tunneling regime. We find that the useful heat flux out from the normal metal is always reduced as compared to its magnitude under the static and quasi-static drive conditions. Our results are useful to predict the operative conditions of AC driven superconducting electron refrigerators.

Mesoscale and Nanoscale Physics,Superconductivity

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to study the influence of photon - assisted tunneling (PAT) on the heat flow in normal - metal - superconductor tunnel junctions. Specifically, the authors explored how the heat - transfer characteristics in this hybrid structure would change under high - frequency radiation driving. Through theoretical analysis, they found that compared with static or quasi - static driving conditions, PAT would reduce the useful heat extracted from the normal - metal electrode and generally increase the heat dissipation in the superconductor.

### Main problems
1. **Influence of high - frequency radiation on heat transfer**: The paper mainly focuses on whether high - frequency radiation (responsible for the PAT phenomenon) will enhance or suppress heat transfer in the NIS system under specific conditions.
2. **Change in refrigeration effect**: The study pointed out that under the influence of PAT, the refrigeration effect of the normal conductor would be weakened, while the heat dissipation in the superconductor would generally increase.
3. **Application prospects**: These results are not favorable for NIS junctions in high - frequency applications, but are very useful for determining the operating conditions of AC - driven electronic refrigerators.

### Research background
- Photon - assisted tunneling (PAT) is a phenomenon that occurs when a relatively high - frequency electromagnetic field is applied to a tunnel junction with non - linear current - voltage characteristics. In this case, the radiation field is slow enough to ensure the adiabatic evolution of electron energy levels.
- NIS tunnel junctions (normal - metal - insulator - superconductor) exhibit highly non - linear current - voltage characteristics at low temperatures, usually caused only by quasiparticle tunneling.
- Under DC bias or low - frequency AC radiation, NIS junctions can achieve a refrigeration effect in certain operating modes, that is, the normal metal is cooled while the superconductor is overheated.

### Research methods and conclusions
- The authors established a theoretical framework and model to describe the heat - flow and charge - flow behaviors of the system, and used tools such as Bogoliubov - de Gennes equations and Green functions for analysis.
- The results show that under the action of PAT, the refrigeration efficiency of the normal - metal electrode is always lower than that under static or quasi - static driving conditions.
- These findings are helpful for predicting and optimizing the operating conditions of AC - driven superconducting electronic refrigerators, although for high - frequency applications, the presence of PAT may reduce their performance.

### Formula examples
The paper involves multiple formulas. The following are the Markdown representations of some key formulas:

- Time - dependent relationship of superconducting chemical potential:
\[
\hbar\frac{\partial\chi}{\partial t}=-e\phi_S
\]

- Form of Green function in frequency representation:
\[
G^{R(A)}_{\epsilon,\epsilon - \hbar\omega}=\sum_{n,m}J_n(\alpha)J_m(\alpha)G^{R(A)}_0(\epsilon - n\hbar\omega_0,\epsilon - \hbar\omega - m\hbar\omega_0)
\]

- Average heat - flow formula:
\[
Q_S=\frac{e^2}{2R_t}\int d\epsilon g_\epsilon\sum_nJ_n^2(\alpha)[f^S_1(\epsilon)-f^N_1(\epsilon + n\hbar\omega_0)]d\epsilon
\]

Through these studies, the authors provided an important theoretical basis for understanding the influence of high - frequency radiation on heat transfer in NIS tunnel junctions and provided guidance for practical applications.