E.V. Bezuglyi,A.S. Vasenko,E.N. Bratus',V.S. Shumeiko,G. Wendin
Abstract:We calculate the subgap current in planar superconducting tunnel junctions with thin-film diffusive leads. It is found that the subharmonic gap structure of the tunnel current scales with an effective tunneling transparency which may exceed the junction transparency by up to two orders of magnitude depending on the junction geometry and the ratio between the coherence length and the elastic scattering length. These results provide an alternative explanation of anomalously high values of the subgap current in tunnelling experiments often ascribed to imperfection of the insulating layer. We also discuss the effect of finite lifetime of quasiparticles as the possible origin of additional enhancement of multiparticle tunnel currents.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is the behavior of the subgap current and its relationship with tunnel transparency in a planar superconducting tunnel junction when the electrodes are diffusive. Specifically, the authors focus on the subgap quasiparticle current in superconducting junctions under a small voltage \( eV < 2\Delta \), which is a hot topic in theoretical and experimental research.
### Background of the paper
1. **Subgap current**: In a superconducting junction, when the applied voltage \( eV < 2\Delta \), due to the multiparticle tunneling (MPT) process, a subgap current will be generated. The intensity of this current strongly depends on the quality of the insulating layer and can be enhanced by factors such as disorder, local electron states, and pinholes.
2. **Discrepancy between existing theories and experiments**: Although theoretically the subharmonic gap structure (SGS) of the subgap tunneling current should be related to the tunnel transparency \( D \), in macroscopic tunnel junction experiments, the scaling parameter of SGS is usually much larger than theoretically predicted, and there is a smooth residual current at low voltages.
### Goals of the paper
1. **Re - examine the subgap current**: The authors re - examined the problem of the subgap current in macroscopic tunnel junctions, especially considering the influence of diffusive electrodes and the planar junction geometry.
2. **Explain experimental results**: By introducing the effective tunnel transparency \( D_{\text{eff}} \), the authors provided a new explanation that under certain conditions, the scaling parameter of SGS can significantly exceed the actual tunnel transparency \( D \).
### Main findings
1. **Effective tunnel transparency**: For a planar junction with thin - layer diffusive electrodes, the effective tunnel transparency \( D_{\text{eff}} \) can be expressed as:
\[
D_{\text{eff}} = \left(\frac{3\xi_0^2}{\ell d}\right) D
\]
where \( \xi_0=\sqrt{\frac{D}{2\Delta}} \) is the diffusive coherence length, \( \ell \) is the elastic scattering length, \( d \) is the electrode thickness, and \( D \) is the diffusion coefficient.
2. **Enhancement effect**: For Al junctions, when \( \ell \sim d = 50 \text{ nm} \) and \( \xi_0 = 300 \text{ nm} \), the enhancement factor can reach 100.
3. **Circuit theory explanation**: The authors also used circuit theory to explain the subgap current, describing it as an infinite network in energy space, where part of the current flows through the tunnel resistance connecting adjacent nodes.
### Experimental significance
1. **Explain experimental phenomena**: This theory explains the enhanced SGS phenomenon observed in experiments, especially in low - transparency junctions, where there is an enhanced subgap current even if the insulating layer is of good quality.
2. **Application prospects**: These results are of great significance for understanding the decoherence problem in superconducting qubits and are helpful for optimizing the design and performance of superconducting devices.
In conclusion, this paper reinterprets the behavior of the subgap current in superconducting tunnel junctions by introducing the concept of effective tunnel transparency, providing a new theoretical basis for understanding and optimizing superconducting devices.