A Bard is Born: A New Era of Poetry Translation by ChatGPT-4
Xingzhong Guan
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/07374836.2024.2365778
2024-07-13
Translation Review
Abstract:No potential conflict of interest was reported by the author(s). 1. Humblé, "Machine Translation and Poetry, " 42–50. 2. Tomonobu, "Phrase-Based Statistical Machine," 53–56. 3. Dunder, "Automatic Machine," 1034–39. 4. 《春江花月夜 历代咏春诗鉴赏》, 24–25. https://so.gushiwen.cn/shiwenv_3aed26d1fa99.aspx 5. Full texts of Google and Bing Translate are available upon request. Most translations can be found online. 6. Liu, "An Analysis," 1505–31. See also Moorkens, Translation Quality Assessment , 18, 23. 7. Maurya, "Machine Translation Evaluation," 543. 8. The translations in the middle column were generated by Bing, while those on the right were produced by Google Translate. This data was retrieved on January 9, 2024. Refer to for a comparative analysis with other English versions. 9. Linell, "Discourse across Boundaries," 153–54. Linell conceptualizes all forms of communication as recontextualization, a process of extracting from their original context and reintegrating into a new one, which involves "the dynamic transfer-and-transformation of something from one discourse/text-in-context to another." 10. Venuti, "Genealogies of Translation Theory," 129. 11. Budd, Chinese Poems , 37–40. https://www.hellenicaworld.com/China/Literature/CharlesBudd/en/ChinesePoems.html 12. Fletcher, Gems of Chinese Verse , 169–70. https://archive.org/details/gemsofchinesever00fletiala/page/n7/mode/2up. 13. Barnstone, The Anchor Book , 94–96. 14. Cranmer-Byng, A Lute of Jade , 68–70. https://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/390. 15. Mathers, The Garden of Bright Waters, 68 . https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/9920/pg9920-images.html#Poet_Looks_at_the_Moon. 16. 许渊冲, 唐诗三百首, 21. https://c.m.163.com/news/a/FNSR5KFK0530SFP3.html 17. Accessed on December 23, 2023. 18. 王继宗, "欢欣与惆怅交织的浪漫", 135. Also方文飞, "鸿雁鱼龙双双飞," 40. The phrase "光不度" (guāng bù dù) in Chinese is somewhat ambiguous and may not be immediately clear even to native speakers. Its interpretation in "鸿雁高飞光不度" remains a contentious topic among scholars, underscoring the intricate nature of Chinese poetic exegesis. Various readings exist: one posits that geese are unable to surpass or fly beyond the moonlight, while another suggests they navigate by it. A further interpretation sees the geese as messengers returning with a distant lover's words, and yet another proposes that they fly so high that their reflection is not seen in the river. Flying geese cannot catch the moving beam of moonlight that connects people is also an option. 19. https://readabilityformulas.com/readability-scoring-system.php#formulaResults. 20. Accessed on November 16, 2023. It is worth noting that it is somehow illogical for a fish to "reach up high" to be "with the moon" in the translation. This is not something that would typically occur in a human translation. 21. See note 13 above, 96. 22. Perfect, "Rhyme and Reason," 728. 23. Accessed on January 9, 2024. 24. Shaw, "The Multisensory Image," 175–78. 25. Poyatos, Textual Translation , 92. 26. https://www.magyarirok.hu/petofi-sandor/s/szabadsag-szerelem. 27. Accessed on April 18, 2024, for V1 and V2. An online version of V3 can be found at http://www.studyinhungary.hu/blog/sandor-petofi-the-revolutionary-poet-was-born-200-years-ago 28. https://lyricstranslate.com. The right column is a literal translation of the poem 29. Accessed on March 28, 2024. 30. Moniz and Parra Escartín, Towards Responsible Machine Translation , 71–113. 31. See note 21 and also the discussion about translation of "光不度." Xingzhong Guan is a professor at the School of Translation and Interpreting, Beijing Language and Culture. He is the translator of the seminal work, Translators through History (2012), which is invaluable to students, scholars, and professionals in the field of translation studies. He also served as the editor of Sir Harold Acton's Popular Chinese Plays , a collection comprising thirty-eight traditional plays. His research primarily focuses on intercultural communication between the East and the West. He was a visiting scholar at Kent State University from 2022 to 2023.