Abstract:Purpose This study examines (1) the extent of key audit matters (KAMs) reported by auditors is related to accounting estimates, (2) whether measurement uncertainty and management bias affect auditors to do so and (3) whether the use of accounting estimates, given the measurement uncertainty and management bias reported in KAMs adversely affects the decision usefulness of accounting information. Design/methodology/approach Data on key audit matters, accounting estimates, measurement uncertainty, management bias, etc. were collected from the auditor's reports of 351 sample Chinese listed firms. It employs regression analyses to assess the hypotheses on issues affecting the report of these key audit matters and the impacts on the decision usefulness of accounting information. Findings Fair value and impairment loss estimations make up of 2.6 and 44.1% of the 606 KAMs identified, respectively. Measurement uncertainty is positively, while management bias is negatively, affecting auditors report KAMs related to accounting estimates. The use of accounting estimates in firms where their auditors reported the KAMs related to accounting estimates does not enhance the value and predictive relevance of reported earnings. The assurance works on, and reporting of, KAMs served as a “red flag” about the accounting estimates. Practical implications The use of accounting estimates does not always lead to enhanced decision-useful accounting information. Auditors, in their stewardship role, shall ensure that the measurement uncertainty issue is appropriately identified, addressed and verified. In addition, they shall provide an effective check-and-balance to the accounting discretion managers have in providing decision-useful information from opportunistic reporting. Originality/value This study examines the proposition that while the use of estimates can enhance the decision usefulness of accounting information, it can also induce measurement uncertainty and management bias into financial reporting.

The Effect of Reporting Key Audit Matters on Audit Fees and Financial Reporting Quality: Evidence from Hong Kong

Short Selling and Financial Reporting Quality: Evidence from Chinese AH Shares

Key Audit Matters and the Pricing of Audit Services: Evidence from Hong Kong

Annual report inquiry letters, disclosure of key audit matters and audit fees: Evidence from Chinese A-share listed companies

Audit Report Information Improvement and Earnings Management

The effect of key audit matters on the association of credit risk and earnings quality

Does the disclosure of key audit matters improve the audit quality for sustainable development: Empirical evidence from China

Informativeness of Key Audit Matters: Evidence from China

Research on the influence of key audit matters on the audit quality of commercial banks-Evidence from China

Key Audit Matters and Debt Contracting: Evidence from China

Does the Mandatory Disclosure of Audit Information Affect Analysts’ Information Acquisition?

Consequences of the implementation of expanded audit reports with key audit matters (KAMs) on audit quality

The Consequences of Allowing Home Country Auditors to Audit Cross-listed Firms: Evidence from Hong Kong-listed H Share Firms

Does the Mandatory Disclosure of Audit Information Affect Analysts' Information Acquisition?

The Determinants and Impact of Key Audit Matters Disclosure in the Auditor’s Report

Influence of external and internal auditors on key audit matters (KAMs) reporting in Thailand

What underlies key audit matters? Evidence from Taiwan

Measurement uncertainty and management bias in accounting estimates: the perspective of key audit matters reported by Chinese firms' auditors

Positive Spillover Effect and Audit Quality: a Study of Cancelling China’s Dual Audit System

The impact of key audit matters on goodwill accounting and investment behavior: Evidence from China

The Effect of Disclosing Key Audit Matters and Accounting Standard Precision on the Audit Expectation Gap