Abstract:In this issue of Endoscopy , Soriani et al. [1] evaluate the efficacy of over-the-scope (OTS) clips versus through-the-scope (TTS) clips as a primary treatment in Forrest Ia–IIb peptic ulcer bleeding. They conducted a multicenter, randomized controlled trial (RCT) in four Italian and one Spanish center. This was the first trial to provide head-to-head comparison between two mechanical modalities in endoscopic hemostatic treatment for high risk peptic ulcer bleeding. The negative result of the 30-day rebleeding rate after successful initial hemostasis was 1.6% (1/61) and 3.9% (2/51) for patients treated with OTS clips and TTS clips, respectively (RR = 0.42, 95%CI 0.04–4.53; P =0.47). However, the successful initial hemostasis and overall clinical success rates were higher in the OTS clip group than in the TTS clip group (98.4% vs. 78.4%, P =0.001; 96.7% vs. 74.5%, P =0.001, respectively) with an absolute risk reduction of 20%. "These data support the recommendation of the ESGE guideline to use over-the-scope clips as the primary treatment only in selected patients with peptic ulcer bleeding who have a high risk of hemostatic failure with through-the scope clips." This study emphasizes an important factor for successful initial hemostasis and overall clinical success, which is the expertise of the endoscopist. The study included only experienced endoscopists who had already placed 30 or more OTS clips, resulting in near perfect initial hemostasis and overall clinical success in the OTS clip group. This information was supported by our previous trial, which concluded that OTS clips could be helpful as a primary hemostasis modality in large (≥1.5cm) bleeding peptic ulcers only in experienced hands [2]. Other previous RCTs on this topic [3] [4] have also emphasized the need for endoscopist experience in OTS clip use by setting a protocol of a 2-week OTS clip training program [3] or including only endoscopists who performed ≥20 OTS clip applications per year [4] in the study. Therefore, the results of the Soriani et al. study might not be applicable to general endoscopists. The learning curve for the use of OTS clips is warranted to ensure excellent outcomes for initial hemostasis. Compared with TTS clips, OTS clips can capture a larger amount of tissue and anchor onto the base of the fibrotic ulcer, and therefore have a higher clip retention rate [5]. The nitinol clip has a high tensile strength and compresses the bleeding artery firmly [5]. Brandler et al. reported three characteristics of actively bleeding ulcers that would make OTS clip use appropriate at the index endoscopy: 1) size >2cm plus a vessel ≥2mm; 2) location around the major arteries (posterior wall of the duodenal bulb and lesser curvature of the body); and 3) presence of a deep, excavated, or fibrotic base [6]. Consequently, the European Society of Gastrointestinal Endoscopy (ESGE) suggest using a cap-mounted clip in these three scenarios as first-line treatment (weak recommendation, low quality of evidence) [7]. In the current study, among patients with failed TTS clip hemostasis (n=11), the majority (7/11; 63.6%) had fibrotic-based ulcers, 3/11 (27.3%) had ulcers at the posterior wall of the duodenal bulb, and one patient (9.1%) had a large vessel [1]. Subsequently, all 11 patients underwent successful endoscopic hemostasis with OTS clip application [1]. These data support the recommendation of the ESGE guideline to use OTS clips as the primary treatment only in selected patients who have a high risk of hemostatic failure with TTS clips. In summary, OTS clips should not be used routinely as a first-line endoscopic hemostatic method for peptic ulcer bleeding. Patients with fibrotic-based or large ulcers sitting on top of a large vessel or ulcers at a high risk location may be selected for OTS clip application as an initial treatment, as these patients would benefit from this approach without being overtreated. Article published online: 24 June 2024 © 2024. Thieme. All rights reserved. Georg Thieme Verlag KG Rüdigerstraße 14, 70469 Stuttgart, Germany

Reduced mortality for over-the-scope clips (OTSC) versus surgery for refractory peptic ulcer bleeding: a retrospective study

Over-the-scope clip as first-line treatment of peptic ulcer bleeding: a multicenter randomized controlled trial (TOP Study)

Systematic Review with Network Meta-Analysis: Dual Therapy for High-Risk Bleeding Peptic Ulcers

Meta‐analysis: Over‐the‐scope clips in patients at high risk of re‐bleeding following upper gastrointestinal tract bleeding

Over-the-Scope Clips Versus Standard Endoscopic Treatment for First Line Therapy of Non-variceal Upper Gastrointestinal Bleeding: Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis

Transcatheter Arterial Embolization Compared With Surgery for Uncontrolled Peptic Ulcer Bleeding: A Population-based Cohort Study

Efficacy and safety of over-the-scope-clips in the therapy of acute nonvariceal upper gastrointestinal bleeding: Meta-analysis

Over-the-scope clip as first-line treatment of peptic ulcer bleeding: is it suitable for all?

Over-the-scope-clips versus standard treatment in high-risk patients with acute non-variceal upper gastrointestinal bleeding: a randomised controlled trial (STING-2)

Comparison of Over-the-Scope Clips to Standard Endoscopic Treatment as the Initial Treatment in Patients With Bleeding From a Nonvariceal Upper Gastrointestinal Cause

Comparison of Over-the-Scope Clips to Standard Endoscopic Treatment As the Initial Treatment in Patients with Bleeding from a Nonvariceal Upper Gastrointestinal Cause A Randomized Controlled Trial

Randomized Comparison of a Novel Hemostatic Clip (resolution Clip™) to Combined Epinephrine Injection and Heater Probe (HP) Thermocoagulation in Endoscopic Control of Peptic Ulcer Bleeding (PUB)

Endoscopic hemostasis for peptic ulcer bleeding: systematic review and meta-analyses of randomized controlled trials

Embolization versus surgery for peptic ulcer bleeding after failed endoscopic hemostasis: a meta-analysis

Retrospective study of 189 cases of acute perforated peptic ulcer: safety and efficacy of over-the-scope-clip based endoscopic closure

S3804 Over-the-Scope Clips for Hemostasis in Post-Variceal Banding Ulcer Bleeding: A Case Series

Management of bleeding peptic duodenal ulcer refractory to endoscopic treatment: surgery or transcatheter arterial embolization as first-line therapy? A retrospective single-center study and systematic review

Over-the-Scope Clip Applications as First-Line Therapy in the Treatment of Upper Non-variceal Gastrointestinal Bleeding, Perforations, and Fistulas

Prophylactic Angiographic Embolisation after Endoscopic Control of Bleeding to High-Risk Peptic Ulcers: a Randomised Controlled Trial.

Over-the-scope clip as a rescue treatment for massive bleeding due to Dieulafoy lesion at the colorectal anastomosis: A case report

Clinical outcomes of the over‐the‐scope clip closure after duodenal endoscopic submucosal dissection: A multicenter retrospective study