Abstract:Introduction: For academics selecting a target journal to submit a manuscript is a critical decision with career implications. In medical education, research conducted in 2016 found that authors were influenced by multiple factors such as a journal's prestige and its mission. However, since this research was conducted the publishing landscape has shifted to include a broader variety of journals, an increased threat of predatory journals, and new publishing models. This study updates and expands upon how medical education authors decide which journal to submit to with the aim of describing the motivational factors and journal characteristics that guide authors' decision making. Methods: The authors conducted five qualitative focus groups in which twenty-two medical education authors and editors participated. During the focus groups participants were engaged in a discussion about how they select a journal to submit their manuscripts. Audio from all focus groups was transcribed. Transcripts were analyzed using codebook thematic analysis. Results: Participants considered multiple factors when selecting a target journal. Factors included a journal's impact, the scope of a journal, journal quality, and technical factors (e.g., word limits). Participants also described how social factors influenced their process and that open access plays a role that could both encourage or deter submission. Discussion: The findings describe the motivational factors and influential signals that guide authors in their journal selection decision making. These findings confirm, extend, and update journal selection factors reported in medical education and other disciplines. Notably, these findings emphasize the role of social factors, relationships and personal experiences, which were absent from previous work. Additionally, we observed increased consideration of OA and a shift away from an emphasis on journal prestige.

A Guide for Submissions to the Journal of Economic Education Instruction Section

Facilitating Professional Development of Primary-and Secondary-School Teachers via Editorial Intentions Embodied in Educational Periodicals:Starting from the Practicality Configuration in the Contents of Such Periodicals

Publishing an applied statistics paper: Guidance and advice from editors

Publishing and Scholarship in Economic Education: A Catalog and Assessment

Editorial: How to develop a quality research article and avoid a journal desk rejection

Exploring the Black Box of Journal Manuscript Review: A Survey of Social Science Journal Editors

Teaching Writing and Communication in a Mathematical Modeling Course

Economic Education Retrospective

How do editors use editorials to lead their journals? Insights from the field of human resource management

Trends and Challenges in the Field of Education Finance and Economics Research

Message from Editor in chief

Making Meaning Matter: an Editor's Perspective on Publishing Qualitative Research

Exploring instructional strategies to develop prospective elementary teachers' children’s literature book evaluation skills for science, ecology and environmental education

Quick start guide: how to review teaching cases

A guide for social science journal editors on easing into open science

Who Publishes in Economic Education? A Bibliographic Analysis of the First 50 Years of the Journal of Economic Education

Editorial: What Makes for a Great Applications and Case Studies Paper?

"The best home for this paper": A qualitative study of how authors select where to submit manuscripts

The Practical Journal Article: Writing to Be Read by Professionals in the Field

Writing like a scientist: a research assignment for undergraduates inspired by the publishing process

Impact of the Society for Pediatric Dermatology Mentorship Award Program on Careers in Pediatric Dermatology: Workforce Implications