Abstract:<section class="article-section__content"><h3 class="article-section__sub-title section1"> Research Summary</h3><p>Prior crisis‐response literature outlines zones of conformity (i.e., response meets stakeholder expectations), underconformity (i.e., response falls short of expectations), and overconformity (i.e., response exceeds expectations). We utilize a mixed‐method approach to empirically test the impact of different response strategies on customers (study 1: experiment) and investors (study 2: event study). We not only find empirical support that a conforming strategy outperforms both non‐conforming strategies concerning stakeholders' affective evaluations of reputation, but extend this proposition to stakeholders' cognitive evaluations of reputation and the financial implications for the firm. The most counterintuitive finding is that overconforming strategies result in lower firm reputation and stock returns relative to conforming strategies. Thus, exceeding stakeholder expectations during a crisis can have unintended negative consequences.</p></section><section class="article-section__content"><h3 class="article-section__sub-title section1"> Managerial Summary</h3><p>How should firms react to product recalls? Previous research suggests that exceeding expectations of external stakeholders should have a neutral or even positive impact on firm reputation and financial performance, while falling short of expectations should have a negative impact. In this paper, we test the impact of different product recall strategies. The most counterintuitive finding is that exceeding stakeholder expectations during a product crisis can have unintended negative consequences on both customers and investors.</p><p>This article is protected by copyright. All rights reserved.</p></section>

Convergence of crisis response strategy and source credibility: Who can you trust?

The Role of Corporate Reputation and Crisis Response Strategies in Data Breach Management.

When Things Go Wrong: Account Strategy Following a Corporate Crisis Event

‘To trust or not to trust’: The impact of social media influencers on the reputation of corporate brands in crisis

How Does Corporate Reputation Affect Customer Loyalty in a Corporate Crisis?

The Role of CSR in Crises: Integration of Situational Crisis Communication Theory and the Persuasion Knowledge Model

The crisis‐response match: An empirical investigation

Media Frames and Crisis Events: Understanding the Impact on Corporate Reputations, Responsibility Attributions, and Negative Affect

Unraveling the Anchoring Effect of Crisis Communication in Cyberattack Spillover Crises

The Effects of Corrective Communication and Employee Backup on the Effectiveness of Fighting Crisis Misinformation

Corporate Hypocrisy: Overcoming the Threat of Inconsistent Corporate Social Responsibility Perceptions

The Impact of Corporate Strategies for Image Restoration on Consumer Trust in Crisis Events: the Moderating Role of Prosocial Motivation

Do instructing and adjusting information make a difference in crisis responsibility attribution? Merging fear appeal studies with the defensive attribution hypothesis

Surviving a Crisis: How Crisis Type and Psychological Distance Can Inform Corporate Crisis Responses

The Value of Brand Fans during a Crisis: Exploring the Roles of Response Strategy, Source, and Brand Identification

The role of empathy in crisis communication: Providing a deeper understanding of how organizational crises and crisis communication affect reputation

Will comments change your opinion? The persuasion effects of online comments and heuristic cues in crisis communication

Activating constructive employee behavioural responses in a crisis: Examining the effects of pre‐crisis reputation and crisis communication strategies on employee voice behaviours

When good becomes bad: the role of corporate crisis and issue congruence

Responses Toward Corporate Crisis and Corporate Advertising

CSR communication on social media: the impact of source and framing on message credibility, corporate reputation and WOM