Abstract:Even though peer process feedback is an often used tool to enhance the effectiveness of collaborative learning environments like PBL, the conditions under which it is best facilitated still need to be investigated. Therefore, this study investigated the effects of individual versus shared reflection and goal setting on students’ individual contributions to the group and their academic achievement. In addition, the influence of prior knowledge on the effectiveness of peer feedback was studied. In this pretest—intervention—posttest study 242 first year students were divided into three conditions: condition 1 (individual reflection and goal setting), condition 2 (individual and shared reflection and goal setting), and condition 3 (control group). Results indicated that the quality of individual contributions to the tutorial group did not improve after receiving the peer feedback, nor did it differ between the three conditions. With regard to academic achievement, only males in conditions 1 and 2 showed better academic achievement compared with condition 3. However, there was no difference between both ways of reflection and goal setting with regard to achievement, indicating that both ways are equally effective. Nevertheless, it is still too early to conclude that peer feedback combined with reflection and goal setting is not effective in enhancing students’ individual contributions. Students only had a limited number of opportunities to improve their contributions. Therefore, future research should investigate whether an increase in number of tutorial group meetings can enhance the effectiveness of peer feedback. In addition, the effect of quality of reflection and goal setting could be taken into consideration in future research.

Preservice mathematics teachers’ beliefs about peer feedback, perceptions of their peer feedback message, and emotions as predictors of peer feedback accuracy and comprehension of the learning task

Investigating peer-assessment strategies for mathematics pre-service teacher learning on formative assessment

Students’ perceptions of the peer-feedback experience in MOOCs

Peer-to-peer dialogue about teachers’ written feedback enhances students’ understanding on how to improve writing skills

Roles, relationships and emotions: Student teachers’ understanding of feedback as interpersonal

Supporting Peer Feedback on Learning Strategies: Effects on Self-Efficacy and Feedback Quality

Oral corrective feedback: Pre-service English as a second language teachers’ beliefs and practices

Peer Feedback in the Mathematics Classroom

The affective effect: Exploring undergraduate students’ emotions in giving and receiving peer feedback

Text quality and changing perceptions of teacher feedback and affective-motivational variables: a study with secondary EFL students

Relations between third grade teachers' depressive symptoms and their feedback to students, with implications for student mathematics achievement

Developing Preservice Mathematics Teachers' Self-Efficacy Through Peer Tutoring

Effectiveness Of Peer Feedback On Second Language Learners

Preservice teachers’ perceptions of feedback: The importance of timing, purpose, and delivery

Midterm peer feedback in problem-based learning groups: the effect on individual contributions and achievement

Evaluating the Impact of Two Dialogical Feedback Methods for Improving Pre-Service Teacher's Perceived Confidence and Competence to Teach Physical Education Within Authentic Learning Environments

The Nature and Effectiveness of Peer Feedback during an Early Clinical Experience in an Elementary Education Program

Teacher Feedback and Students’ Self-Regulated Learning in Mathematics: A Comparison Between a High-Achieving and a Low-Achieving Secondary Schools

“Does My Teacher Believe I Can Improve?”: The Role of Meta-Lay Theories in ESL Learners’ Mindsets and Need Satisfaction

Making learning effective – quantity and quality of pre-service teachers’ feedback

Exploring the Emotional Responses of Undergraduate Students to Assessment Feedback: Implications for Instructors