Abstract:Background: Feedback is a crucial element in learning. While studies in the field of healthcare professions education have highlighted the process of educators feeding back to learners, relatively little investigation exists on learners feeding back to educators in Asian cultures. Studies show that recipients of effective feedback develop educational skills and reflective practice, but the process of giving feedback seems to have been mainly studied through surveys and questionnaires. Such research offers little to no insights on feedback providers' and recipients' experiences of feedback. To fill the gap, in the context of multi-source feedback, we investigate medical students, residents, and nurses feedback giving to clinical educators (and their receiving of this) following a case presentation training course. We aim to understand the facilitators and inhibitors that encourage and/or prevent feedback provision alongside educators' uptake and reactions. Methods: We used semi-structured group interviews. Participants comprised five different categories of participants: year-4 medical students (n = 6); residents (n = 5); nurses (n = 4); junior clinical educators (n = 9); senior clinical educators (n = 3). We asked them about their experiences of providing feedback to educators and educators receiving of feedback on their teaching. Group interviews were conducted in the largest healthcare institution in Taiwan. Data were analysed using thematic Framework Analysis and managed in ATLAS.ti 8.0. Results: We identified two major themes with respective sub-themes: (1) Factors affecting feedback giving (including desire for improvement, feedback content, process of feedback, feedback fears, feedback prevention and medical hierarchy); and (2) Educators' reactions to receiving feedback (including validity of feedback, face-saving and emotional reactions to receiving feedback). Conclusions: Feedback provision to educators on their teaching, and educators' receiving of this feedback in an Asian culture brings forth issues around medical hierarchy, in-person feedback and face-saving, which have important implications for effective and optimal delivery of feedback. Curricular developers should consider the context of feedback (e.g. anonymously online), facilitating students as active participants for the development of educational quality, and educators' mindful practice when engaging with student feedback.

The Nature and Effectiveness of Peer Feedback during an Early Clinical Experience in an Elementary Education Program

Peer coach during field experiences: cultivating teacher candidates’ peer feedback and reflective practices

Evaluating the Impact of Two Dialogical Feedback Methods for Improving Pre-Service Teacher's Perceived Confidence and Competence to Teach Physical Education Within Authentic Learning Environments

Examination of the Quality and Effectiveness of Peer Feedback and Self‐reflection Exercises Among Medical Students

Preservice teachers’ perceptions of feedback: The importance of timing, purpose, and delivery

The Development of Technology-Enhanced Performance-Based Peer Feedback to Support Teacher Candidate Practice and Child Outcomes

Students’ Experiences of Peer Observed Teaching: A Qualitative Interview Study

Student teachers’ perceptions of feedback as an aid to reflection for developing effective practice in the classroom

Actual and Perceived Feedback Delivery During Athletic Training Clinical Education With and Without the Use of Bug-in-Ear Technology

Supporting Peer Feedback on Learning Strategies: Effects on Self-Efficacy and Feedback Quality

Peer Critiquing in Scientific Inquiry: Enhancing Preservice Teachers' Reasoning, Epistemic Knowledge, and Scientific Argumentation through Innovative Teaching Strategies in an Undergraduate Science Content Course

Effectiveness Of Peer Feedback On Second Language Learners

Reciprocal Student–Teacher Feedback: Effects on Perceived Quality of Cooperation and Teacher Health

Midterm peer feedback in problem-based learning groups: the effect on individual contributions and achievement

Nature and Quality of Interactions Between Elementary School Children Using Video-Modeling and Peer-to-Peer Evaluation With and Without Structured Video Feedback

Medical students', residents', and nurses's feedback to clinical educators in Taiwan: A qualitative study

Pre-service early childhood teachers' experiences on teacher interaction in childcare practice institutions

Peer Coaching as a Faculty Development Tool: A Mixed Methods Evaluation

A Qualitative Analysis on the Effectiveness of Peer Feedback in Team-Based Learning

Peer Teaching in High-Fidelity Simulation: Participant Experiences and Reflections

E-Peer Coaching: A Model to Support Rural Special Education Field Placements